AFRASIAN PHONOLOGY Tlazoltéotl
c-AFRASIAN-3_phonology.htm
K3-'pr, 4th Dynasty

PROTO-LANGUAGE PHONEMES

in IE and Afrasian

(Hieroglyphic Egyptian and Arabic)

(Nostratic Hypothesis)

by Patrick C. Ryan

(2/12/2001)

Copyright 1998 Patrick C. Ryan

SUMMARY OF PHONOLOGICAL CHANGES

FROM PL TO AFRASIAN





Assumptions

    1. Nostratic, from which IE and Afrasian developed, had gone through a Pontic stage, during which the earlier contrasts of CE, CA, and CO, were supplemented by glides: CyE, CA, and CwO.

      a. E, A, and O were leveled to A, yielding: CyA, CA, and CwA, which became phonemic.

        1). A (open central vowel) may have had a stress-accented allophone of 6 (schwa = close central vowel).

      b. This vocalic development enabled Ablaut gradations to take place in IE, and vowel patterning in Semitic (but not Egyptian).

    2. A Middle Eastern and Southwestern Asian areal phenomenon is the development of "emphatic" consonants from consonants followed by the w-glide.

    3. In all Nostratic branches, PL (P)F/FH was voiced to /w/hw/.

      a. Ww was redundant, and was simplified to W.

    4. In all Nostratic branches, PL ¿(y)E became /j/.

    5. Afrasian

      a. Egyptian

        1). All non-labial consonants (i.e. except P[?/H], P[?]W/P[H]W, ([H])W and M) with no glide (ø-glides) merged into the corresponding consonants with y-glides.

          a). M[H]y (from M[H]A and M[H]E) became /wn/ and finally merged into W (/w/, written w).

          b). The pharyngal voiced spirants, ¿y/w, merged into the laryngal voiceless stops, ?y/w.

          c). The labial affricates, P[?/H]W became V([?/H]).

        2). The pharyngal voiceless spirant, HH[y], merged into the laryngal voiceless spirant, H[y].

          a). The laryngal voiceless spirant, Hw, merged into the pharyngal voiceless spirant, HHw.

        3). Aspiration was lost.

          a). The laryngal voiceless stop, ?w, merged into the pharyngal voiceless spirant, HHw.

          b). The laryngal voiceless spirant, Hy, was simplified to /y/, and merged into J.

        4). Glottalization was lost.

        5). The palatal glide was lost after changing N[y] to /L[y]/ in some dialects only (still written [n]); Q[y] to /ng[y]/ (later /g[y]/), written [q](dot-k); X[y] to /ç/, written [S]([hachek-s]); KX[y] to /kç/ (later /h[y]/, written [H]([dot-h]); S[y] to /sh/, written [z]; TS[y] to /tsh/, written [D]([bar-d]) were changed in all dialects.

        6). Every Egyptian consonant developed two different articulations distinguished by those that were followed by the w-glide and those that were not followed by the w-glide; these became phonemic.

          a). The phonemes followed by the w-glide substituted aspiration (h) for the w-glide except in the dorsal series and R([Hw]/[w]) and HH[w], which retained the w-glide:

            1)). The w-glide remained in: K[w] remained /k[w]/, written T(bar-t); KX[w] remained /kx[w]/ (later /hw/), written x(hook-h); X[w] remained /x[w]/, written X(bar-h); Q[w] remained /ng[w]/ (later /g[w]/);

            2)). The w-glide was lost in: R[w] became /R/{uvular /r/}), and occurred as /L/ (velar /l/) in some dialects, both written [r]; HH[w] became /hh/, written [h].

            3)). Aspiration modified the phonemes in: P[h] became /f/, written [f]; T[h] became /th/, written [t];

            4)). Aspiration was eliminated in: V[h] became /v/, written [b]; M[h] became /m/, written [m]; N[h] became /n/, written [n]; S[h] became /s/, written [s]; TS[h] became /ts/ (but later /?/), written [']; .

            5)). Phonemes that did not change were: P remained /p/, written [p]; V remained /v/, written [b]; T remained /t/, written [d]; K remained /k/, written [k]; R remained /r/ (but later /h/), written [3]; W remained /w/, written [w]; J remained /j/, written [j]; M remained /m/, written [m].

            6)). Additional changes were: [z], which had been /sh/, merged with [s] as /s/; and [S]([hachek-s]), which had been /ç/, became /sh/.

        7). These developments resulted in the following consonantal inventory for Egyptian:

        {press to see}



      b. Arabic

        1. The following changes were shared with Germanic:

          a). N[y] was de-nasalized to L[y];

          b). All N[H] was de-nasalized to L;

          c). All consonantal y-glides were eliminated (but J remained);

          d). All voiceless spirants (except H and HH; ¿ is here considered a voiceless pharyngal stop), including those in affricates, were voiced: S became Z and X became g ("gamma" - voiced dorsal spirant);

          e). Glottalization was lost (but ? remained).

          f). The w-glide of the labial stops was eliminated;

          g). P[H] was spirantized to F;

          h). The initial elements of PW, TZ, and Kg assimilated in voicing to the second elements, i.e. became BW, DZ, and Gg;

          i). M[H], L[H] and R[H] were de-aspirated;

          j). Press here for the remaining changes specific to Germanic.



        2. The following changes were shared with Semitic:

          a). T[H] was spirantized to th; K[H] was spirantized to x;

          b). The apical stops and affricates with w-glides became phonemic: T[w] became retroflex (emphatic) T[r]; th[w] became retroflex (emphatic) S[r]; DZ[w] became retroflex (emphatic) D[r]; DZ[Hw] became retroflex (emphatic) Z[r].

          c). R[w] became L*, velar /l/;

          d). [H]W was de-aspirated to W.

          e). w-glides were lost;

          f). Aspirated Z[H] and g[H] were de-voiced and de-aspirated to S and ç, which further developed to sh;

          g). g merged into sh;

          h). The voiced affricates, DZ([H]) and Gg([H]) were simplified to D([H]) and G([H]); then D[H] and G[H] were spirantized to dh and g (voiced dorsal spirant);

          i). Aspirated Q[H] was de-nasalized, de-voiced, and de-aspirated to K* (post-velar /k/);

          j). Q was denasalized to post-velar G*, and merged into K*;

          k). G was palatalized in most dialects to DZH;

          l). P merged into B;

          m). After shifting central A to front af, 6 became i, u, or af, depending on whether the previous consonant had had a y-glide, w-glide, or no glide.

          o). These developments resulted in the following consonantal inventory for Arabic:

          {press to see}



      c. Germanic

        1). Here are the final changes for Germanic, tied to a table.

          a). T[H] was spirantized to th; K[H] was spirantized to x;

          b). [H]W was de-aspirated to w.

          c). w-glides were lost;

          d). The spirants Z([H]) and g([H]) were de-voiced to s and x* (post-velar /x/), including as second elements in affricates;

            1)). The resulting affricate ds was simplified to d;

            2)). The resulting affricate gx* was simplified to g;

            3)). The resulting affricate ds[H] was simplified through /th/ to th;

            4)). The resulting affricate gx*[H] was simplified through /kh/ to x;

          e). Post-velar X* and X*[H] acquired w-glides;

            1)). Post-velar X*[w] and X*[Hw] were de-spirantized to K*[w] and K*[Hw];

              a)). Post-velar K*[w] became k*[w] then shifted forward to k[w];

              b)). Post-velar K*[Hw] became x*[w] then shifted forward to x[w];

          f). Q[H] was de-nasalized (in some dialects, only initially), de-voiced to (n)K*[H] (post-velar /(n)kh*/); and merged into em>K[H]; and shifted forward to (n)x;

          g). Q was denasalized (in some dialects, only initially), devoiced to post-velar (n)k*, and merged into K*; and shifted forward to (n)k;

          h). All laryngals and pharyngals became H, which 'colored' the adjacent vowel based on the presence of former glides or no glide;

          i). Low central A and 6[?] were modified by grammatical Ablaut to either e or o.

          j). These developments resulted in the following consonantal inventory for Germanic:

          {press to see}









the latest revision of this document can be found at

HTTP://WWW.GEOCITIES.COM/Athens/Forum/2803/c-AFRASIAN-3_phonology.htm

Patrick C. Ryan * 9115 West 34th Street - Little Rock, AR 72204-4441 * (501)227-9947

PROTO-LANGUAGE@email.msn.com





Nostratic Phonological Inventory at Pontic Stage

A (6)
P[?], P[?y], P[?w], P[H], P[Hy], P[Hw],
P[?]W, P[?]W[y], (P[?]W), P[H]W, P[H]W[y], (P[H]W),
W, W[y], (W), [H]W, [H]W[y], ([H]W)
T[?], T[?y], T[?w], T[H], T[Hy], T[Hw],
T[?]S, T[?]S[y], T[?]S[w], TS[H], TS[Hy], TS[Hw],
S, S[y], S[w], S[H], S[Hy], S[Hw],
K[?], K[?y], K[?w], K[H], K[Hy], K[Hw],
K[?]X, K[?]X[y], K[?]X[w], KX[H], KX[Hy], KX[Hw],
X, X[y], X[w], X[H], X[Hy], X[Hw],
M, M[y], M[w], M[H], M[Hy], M[Hw], N, N[y], N[w], N[H], N[Hy], N[Hw], Q, Q[y], Q[w], Q[H], Q[Hy], Q[Hw],
R, R[y], R[w], R[H], R[Hy], R[Hw],
?, ?[y], ?[w], H, H[y], H[w], ¿, J, ¿[w], HH, HH[y], HH[w]
[?] indicates glottalization; [H] indicates aspiration; [y] indicates palatal glide; [w] indicates velar glide; Q = /ng/, a voiced dorsal nasal; ? = voiceless laryngal (glottal) stop (/?/); ¿ is a voiced pharyngal fricative (/¿/); HH is a voiceless pharyngal fricative (/bar-h/); J = /j/; W = /w/; parentheses ( ) indicate a phoneme merged with another.






Egyptian Phonological Inventory at Change 1

A (6)
P[?], P[?y], P[?w], P[H], P[Hy], P[Hw],
V[?], V[?y], V[?w], V[H], V[Hy], V[Hw],
W, W[y], (W), [H]W, [H]W[y], ([H]W)
(T[?y]), T[?y], T[?w], (T[Hy]), T[Hy], T[Hw],
(T[?]S[y]), T[?]S[y], T[?]S[w], (TS[H][y]), TS[Hy], TS[Hw],
(S[y]), S[y], S[w], (S[Hy]), S[Hy], S[Hw],
(K[?y]), K[?y], K[?w], (K[Hy]), K[Hy], K[Hw],
K[?]X, K[?]X[y], K[?]X[w], KX[H], KX[Hy], KX[Hw],
(X[y]), X[y], X[w], (X[Hy]), X[Hy], X[Hw],
M, M[y], M[w], W, (W), M[Hw], (N[y]), N[y], N[w], (N[Hy]), N[Hy], N[Hw],
(Q[y]), Q[y], Q[w], (Q[Hy]), Q[Hy], Q[Hw],
(R[y]), R[y], R[w], (R[Hy]), R[Hy], R[Hw],
?[y], (J), ?[w], (H[y]), H[y], H[w], (?[y]), J, (?[w]), (HH[y]), HH[y], HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Egyptian Phonological Inventory at Change 2

A (6)
P[?], P[?y], P[?w], P[H], P[Hy], P[Hw],
V[?], V[?y], V[?w], V[H], V[Hy], V[Hw],
W, W[y], (W), [H]W, [H]W[y], ([H]W)
(T[?y]), T[?y], T[?w], (T[Hy]), T[Hy], T[Hw],
(T[?]S[y]), T[?]S[y], T[?]S[w], (TS[H][y]), TS[Hy], TS[Hw],
(S[y]), S[y], S[w], (S[Hy]), S[Hy], S[Hw],
(K[?y]), K[?y], K[?w], (K[Hy]), K[Hy], K[Hw],
(K[?]X[y]), K[?]X[y], K[?]X[w], (KX[Hy]), KX[Hy], KX[Hw],
(X[y]), X[y], X[w], (X[Hy]), X[Hy], X[Hw],
M, M[y], M[w], W, (W), M[Hw], (N[y]), N[y], N[w], (N[Hy]), N[Hy], N[Hw],
(Q[y]), Q[y], Q[w], (Q[Hy]), Q[Hy], Q[Hw],
(R[y]), R[y], R[w], (R[Hy]), R[Hy], R[Hw],
?[y], (J), ?[w], (H[y]), H[y], (HH[w]), (?[y]), J, (?[w]), (H[y]), (H[y]), HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Egyptian Phonological Inventory at Change 3

A (6)
P[?], P[?y], P[?w], P, P[y], P[w],
V[?], V[?y], V[?w], V, V[y], V[w],
W, W[y], (W), (W), (W[y]), (W)
(T[?y]), T[?y], T[?w], (T[y]), T[y], T[w],
(T[?]S[y]), T[?]S[y], T[?]S[w], (TS[y]), TS[y], TS[w],
(S[y]), S[y], S[w], (S[y]), S[y], S[w],
(K[?y]), K[?y], K[?w], (K[y]), K[y], K[w],
(K[?]X[y]), K[?]X[y], K[?]X[w], (KX[y]), KX[y], KX[w],
(X[y]), X[y], X[w], (X[y]), (X[y]), X[w],
M, M[y], M[w], W, (W), (M[w]), (N[y]), N[y], N[w], (N[y]), (N[y]), (N[w]),
(Q[y]), Q[y], Q[w], (Q[y]), (Q[y]), (Q[w]),
(R[y]), R[y], R[w], (R[y]), (R[y]), (R[w]),
?[y], (J), (HH[w]), (J), (J), (HH[w]), (?[y]), J, (HH[w]), (J), (J), HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Egyptian Phonological Inventory at Change 4

A (6)
(P), (P[y]), (P[w]), P, P[y], P[w],
(V), (V[y]), (V[w]), V, V[y], V[w],
W, W[y], (W), (W), (W[y]), (W)
(T[y]), (T[y]), (T[w]), (T[y]), T[y], T[w],
(TS[y]), (TS[y]), (TS[w]), (TS[y]), TS[y], TS[w],
(S[y]), S[y], S[w], (S[y]), S[y], S[w],
(K[y]), (K[y]), (K[w]), (K[y]), K[y], K[w],
(KX[y]), (KX[y]), (KX[w]), (KX[y]), KX[y], KX[w],
(X[y]), X[y], X[w], (X[y]), (X[y]), X[w],
M, M[y], M[w], W, (W), (M[w]), (N[y]), N[y], N[w], (N[y]), (N[y]), (N[w]),
(Q[y]), Q[y], Q[w], (Q[y]), (Q[y]), (Q[w]),
(R[y]), R[y], R[w], (R[y]), (R[y]), (R[w]),
(J), (J), (HH[w]), (J), (J), (HH[w]), (J), J, (HH[w]), (J), (J), HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Egyptian Phonological Inventory at Change 5

A (6)
(P), (P), (P[w]), P, (P), P[w],
(PF), (PF), (PF[w]), PF, (PF), PF[w],
(V), (V), (V[w]), V, (V), V[w],
W, (W), (W), (W), (W), (W)
(T), (T), (T[w]), (T), (T), T[w],
(/tsh/[D]), (/tsh/[D]), (TS[w]), (/tsh/[D]), (/tsh/[D]), TS[w],
(/sh/[z]), /sh/[z], S[w], (/sh/[z]), (/sh/[z]), S[w],
(K), (K), (K[w]), (K), (K), K[w],
(/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), (/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), (KX[w]), (/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), (/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), KX[w],
(/ç/[S]), /ç/[S], X[w], (/ç/[S]), (/ç/[S]), X[w],
M, (M), M[w], /w/[w], (/w/[w]), (M[w]), (N/L[y]; [n]), N/L[y]; [n], N[w], (N/L[y]; [n]), (N/L[y]; [n]), (N[w]),
(/ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q]), /ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q], Q[w], (/ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q]), (/ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q]), (Q[w]),
(R), (R), R[w], (R), (R), (R[w]),
(J), (J), (HH[w]), (J), (J), (HH[w]), (J), J, (HH[w]), (J), (J), HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Egyptian Phonological Inventory at Change 6

A (6)
(P), (P), (/f/[f]), P, (P), /f/[f],
[b](/v/),
W, (W), (W), (W), (W), (W)
(T), (T), (/th/[t]), (T), (T), /th/[t],
(/tsh/[D]), (/tsh/[D]), (/ts/ to /?/;[']), (/tsh/[D]), (/tsh/[D]), /ts/ to /?/;['],
(/sh/ to /s/; [z]), /sh/[z], S[h], (/sh/ to /s/; [z]), (/sh/ to /s/; [z]), S[h],
(K), (K), (/k[w]/; [T]), (K), (K), /k[w]/; [T],
(/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), (/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), (/kx[w]/ to /h[w]/; [x]), (/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), (/kç/ to /hj/; [H]), /kx[w]/ to /h[w]/; [x],
(/ç/ to /sh/; [S]), /ç/ to /sh/; [S], /x[w]/; [X], (/ç/ to /sh/ [S]), (/ç/ to /sh/; [S]), /x[w]/; [X],
M, (M), M[h], /w/[w], (/w/[w]), (M[h]), (N/L[y]; [n]), N/L[y]; [n], N[h], (N/L[y]; [n]), (N/L[y]; [n]), (N[h]),
(/ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q]), /ng[y]/ to /g[y]; [q], /ng[w]/ to /g[w]/; [g], (/ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q]), (/ng[y]/ to /g[y]/; [q]), (/ng[w]/ to /g[w]/; [g]),
(R), (R), R[w], (R), (R), (R[w]),
(J), (J), (HH[w]), (J), (J), (HH[w]), (J), J, (HH[w]), (J), (J), HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Final Egyptian Phonological Inventory

A (6) {indicated in the alphabetic hieroglyphs}
[p](/p/), [f](/f/),
[b](/v/),
w(/w/)
[d](/t/), [t](/th/),
[D](/tsh/), ['](/ts/ to /?/),
[z](/sh/ to /s/), [s](/s/),
[k](/k/), [T](/kw/),
[H](/kç/ to /hy/); [x](/kxw/ to /hw/),
[S](/ç/ to /sh/); [X](/xw/),
[m](/m/), {[w](/w/)}, [n](/ny/ or /ly/), [n](/n/),
[q](/ngy/ to /gy/), [g](/ngw/ to /gw/),
[3](/r/ to /h/), [r](/rw/ to /R/ or /L/),
[j](/y/), [h](/hh/)

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION







Arabic Phonological Inventory at Change 1

(shared with Germanic)
A (6)
P, (P), (P), F, (F), (F),
BW, (BW), (BW), FW, (FW), (FW),
W, (W), (W), [H]W, ([H]W), ([H]W)
T, (T), T[w], T[H], (T[H]), T[Hw],
DZ, (DZ), DZ[w], DZ[H], (DZ[H]), DZ[Hw],
Z, (Z), Z[w], Z[H], (Z[H]), Z[Hw],
K, (K), K[w], K[H], (K[H]), K[Hw],
Gg, (Gg), Gg[w], Gg[H], (Gg[H]), Gg[Hw],
g, (g), g[w], g[H], (g[H]), g[Hw],
M, (M), M[w], (M), (M), (M[w]), N, L, N[w], (L), (L), L[w], Q, (Q), Q[w], Q[H], (Q[H]), Q[Hw],
R, (R), R[w], (R), (R), R[w],
?, (?), ?[w], H, (H), H[w], ¿, J, ¿[w], HH, (HH), HH[w]

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Arabic Phonological Inventory at Change 2

(shared with Semitic)
af (i, af, u)
B, (B), (B), F, (F), (F),
B, (B), (B), F, (F), (F),
W, (W), (W), (W), (W), (W)
T, (T), T[r], th, (th), S[r],
D, (D), D[r], dh, (dh), Z[r],
Z, (Z), (Z), S, (S), (S),
K, (K), (K), X, (x), (x),
DZH, (DZH), (DZH), g, (g), (g),
(sh), (sh), (sh), sh, (sh), (sh),
M, (M), M, (M), (M), (M), N, L, (N), (L), (L), (L), (K*), (K*), (K*), K*, (K*), (K*),
R, (R), L*, (R), (R), (L*),
?, (?), (?), H, (H), (H), ¿, J, (¿), HH, (HH), (HH)

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION





Arabic Phonological Inventory at Change 3

af (i, af, u)
[b](/b/), [f](/f/)
[b](/bw/ to /b/), [f](/f/),
[w](/w/)
[t](/t/), [T (dot-t)](/T/ {retroflex-t}), [th](/th/), [S (dot-s)](/S/ {retroflex-s})
[d](/ds/ to /dz/ to /d/), [D (dot-d)](/D/) {retroflex-d}, [dh](/dh/), [Z (dot-z)](/Z/ {retroflex-z}),
[z](/z/), [s](/s/),
[k](/k/), [kh](/x/),
[j](/gy/ to /dzh/), [gh](/gh/),
[sh (hachek-s)](/sh/),
[m](/m/), [n](/n/), [l](/l(y)/), [l](/L*/ {velar-L}), [q (dot-k)](/K*/ {post-velar /k/}),
[r](/r/), [l](/L*/ {velar-L}),
[?](/?/), [h](/h/), [¿ (¿)](/¿/), [y](/j/), [hh (dot-h)](/hh/)

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION







Germanic Phonological Inventory

e/o (e[?]/o[?])
p, (p), (p), f, (f), (f),
b, (b), (b), f, (f), (f),
w, (w), (w), (w), (w), (w)
t, (t), (t), th, (th), (th),
d, (d), (d), th, (th), (th),
s, (s), (s), (s), (s), (s),
k, (k), (k), x, (x), (x),
g, (g), (g), x, (x), (x),
k[w], (k[w]), (k[w]), x*[w], (x*[w]), (x*[w]),
m, (m), (m), (m), (m), (m), n, l, (n), (l), (l), L, (n)k, ((n)k), ((n)k), (n)x, ((n)x), ((n)x),
r, (r), (r), (r), (r), L,
H, (H), (H), [H], (H), (H), [H], J, (H), [H], (H), (H)

EXPLANATION OF NOTATION







Final Germanic Phonological Inventory

e/o (e[?]/o[?])
[p](/p/), [f](/f/)
[b], [f](/f/),
[w](/w/)
[t](/t/), [th](/th/),
[d]}, [th](/th/),
[s](/s/),
[k](/k/), [h](/x/),
[g], [h](/x/),
[kw](/kw/), [hw](/xw/),
[m](/m/), [n](/n/), [l](/l(y)/), [(n)k], [(n)h](/{n}x/),
[r](/r/), [l](/L*/ {velar-L}),
[H1(neutral)](from /?/*),
*in my opinion, this is an unnecessary notation.
[H4(e-color)](from /L-P+y/), [H2(a-color)](from /L-P+-/),
[y](/j/), [H3(o-color)](from /L-P+w/)





EXPLANATION OF NOTATION

[?] indicates glottalization; [H] indicates aspiration; [y] indicates palatal glide; [w] indicates velar glide; Q = /ng/, a voiced dorsal nasal; ? = voiceless laryngal (glottal) stop (/?/); ¿ is a voiced pharyngal fricative (/¿/); HH is a voiceless pharyngal fricative (/bar-h/); J = /j/; W = /w/; L-P = laryngal or pharyngal; parentheses ( ) indicate a phoneme merged with another.