by Patrick C. Ryan
(2/12/2001)
R / N-DECLENSION
1. It is well-known that IE exhibits a nominal r/n-declension, termed the neuter heteroclite declension (Brugmann 1888: II, 375-6; III, 103-4); but these paired formants play a modest role in it except in Hittite.
I will demonstrate that the principal employment of -n is to specify definite small
measures of items in the inflectional cases of nouns that are normally conceptualized indefinitely
en masse in the nominative and accusative, the uses in which this use is most likely
to occur.
with T[?]O, 'definite inanimate large plural' = IE *a:ud-, '*mass of water' {cf. Armenian get, 'river'
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE
*(a)udo:r- {cf. Greek údo:r, 'water'}, 'some water (to drink, to
wash, etc.)';
PL K[H]E, 'dark' + X[H]O, 'pack' = IE k^ekw-, 'manure'
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE k^ekwr-, 'piece of manure'.
We must also be able to visualize an ancient stage of the language during which
quantifiers could also precede their nouns as simple adjectival modifiers:
PL ¿A, 'much' + X[H]O, 'compaction', i.e. 'very dense or knobby' = IE *ye/e:kw- {for *H2ekw-), 'liver'
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE
*H2ekwr-, 'piece of liver';
PL ¿A, 'much' + SE, 'emission' = IE *e/e:s- {for *H2es-; cf. Old Latin aser, 'blood'), 'blood'
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE
*H2esr-, 'drop/puddle of blood';
PL ¿A, 'much' + SE, 'seed' = IE *es- {for *H2es-; cf. Gothic asans, 'harvest, summer'), 'harvest(-time), summer'
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE *H2esr-, '*seed/harvest-time,
with NA, 'definite inanimate singular' = IE
H2esn-, 'harvest(ed seed)';
PL FA, 'definite inanimate plural' + T[?]SE, 'finger, teat' = IE u:dh-, 'udder'
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE u:dher-,
'teat, *udder {cf. Latin u:ber, 'udder, teat')';
PL FA, 'definite inanimate plural' + SE, 'seed' = IE *wes- {in Greek ê:ros, from *wesr-, 'spring'}, 'spring, *summer (cf. Latvian vasara, 'summer');
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE *wasr-, '*seed/planting-time';
with NA, 'definite inanimate singular' = IE wasn-,
'*planted seed[-time])' {cf. the interesting pair *esu-s and we/e:su-,
both 'good`];
with RE, 'indefinite inanimate singular' = IE
a:t(h)(e)r- {cf. Old Indian atharvan-, 'fire-priest'}, 'hearth'.
2. Notice that in all these examples a plural formant begins the word, and the purpose of
RE is essentially to re-singularize the idea expanded uses can be seen in
Hittite where, again, it is used to singularize:
e.g. a-ni-u-ur, 'performance`, from a-ni-ya-az-zi, 'performs`
(*aniu-, '*things performed`), also in -shar, -tar, -w/mar, -ttarash).
3.In Hurrian and Urartian, -r, which is much more in evidence, is seen in
-(a)ra/e, e.g. in
PL HHA, 'water' + ¿E, derivative = HA¿(A), 'reflective, metal` = *(h)iya
with RE = *(h)iyari
(IE ayer- {cf. OHG e:r, 'ore`}, '(piece of) ore')
The prevalent IE form, *ayos-, '(*piece of) metal', is a product of **ay- (= Hurrian *(h)iya) + -s from PL SE, unique inanimate singular.
Cf. also in Urartian -eri/e and -âshi in
Din-eri-âshi, 'divinity` ("a quality of any god");
PL P[H]A, 'flat' + T[H]O, distributive = *pata
with RE = patari/e
(IE ayer- {cf. OHG e:r, 'ore`}, '(piece of) ore')
and in Urartian -ure/i, e.g. ag/y-ure/i, 'someone who leads',
shidag/yure/i, 'someone who has built'.
4. But it is in Elamo-Dravidian that PL RE functions vastly more extensively:
Forthcoming. Lexical Parallels between Proto-Indo-European and Other Languages
and John C. Kerns. 1994. The Nostratic Macrofamily A Study in Distant Linguistic Relationship. Trends in Linguistics: Studies and Monographs 74. Berlin, New York City: Mouton de Gruyter
1996. Indo-European and the Nostratic Hypothesis. Studia Nostratica, 1.
Charleston, S. C.: Signum Desktop Publishing
-------------------------1983. Printsipy Kontensivnoi Tipologij. Moscow: Nauka
the latest revision of this document can be found at
HTTP://WWW.GEOCITIES.COM/Athens/Forum/2803/c-AFRASIAN-3_r-N-Declension.htm
Patrick C. Ryan * 9115 West 34th Street - Little Rock, AR
72204-4441* (501)227-9947
PROTO-LANGUAGE@email.msn.com