 |
The Jackson Journal |  |
||
| The On-Line Publication of the John M. Jackson Admiration society | ||||
|
Summer 1999 | |||
|
The Jackson Journal | |
||
| The On-Line Publication of the John M. Jackson Admiration society | ||||
|
Summer 1999 | |||
Website of the Month Summer Vacation – What are JAGniks going to do? As we say goodbye to the JAG cast and crew for the summer, what are all the JAGniks going to do to survive the long season of reruns? Why they will get together on-line! Out on the web there are literally dozens of mailing lists for fans to participate in. When I started this project to find out who created the first JAG mailing list, no one was quite sure, but everyone who wrote me back said whomever did was a brilliant person! What are mailing lists? Mailing lists are a way for a group of people with a common interest to get together and communicate through e-mail. Some of the JAG-related lists are for general conversations about the show, some are dedicated to the actors who brilliantly portray the characters, while still others are a place for unpublished creative authors to share their works with the rest of the JAG fan crew. Lists range from open for all ages to restricted, must be over 18 to participate. There are lists for diehard JAGniks as well as casual fans. Most of all, the lists become communities of friends whose friendships are built on a common love for a certain television show and grow from there. Below is a listing of just some of the various mailing lists I was able to search out on the web. There is a list for everyone! You can sign up to be a member on many of the lists by heading to http:// www.Onelist.com. You can sign up for either regular format where you get each and every message individually or you can receive all messages in a daily digest form. Some of the lists are very active, so be ready for a high volume of mail in your in-box. One person who answered my request for list addresses told me they were on 22 JAG-related mail lists! Warning! Mailing lists can be very addicting! Signs of the addiction are: if you can’t check your e-mail for a couple days you start to hyperventilate, break out into cold sweats, cry uncontrollably because you can’t talk to your cyber-friends, and finally you pass up a good night’s sleep just to catch up on your 500+ messages. Need more ways to communicate? Several of the Internet providers, like AOL and Yahoo, also have chat lists and clubs for JAGniks to share your opinion on the show, its characters and the actors who portray them. Here are the lists! One disclaimer – the Internet is an ever-changing beast. By the time you read this listing, some lists may have closed down while others may have been added. I have done my best to provide the most up-to-date listing. The lists are in alphabetical order. If you want more information about a particular list or want to see a sampling of what they discuss, head to http://www.Onelist.com. For the majority of the lists you will find a brief description and if the list moderator approves, a digest of past discussions.
PATTYOS@aol.com is our
website feature editor. She will be scouting out JMJ (and
JAG) websites and reviewing them so you'll know the best
places on the web to go for your JMJ fix! If you know of
a good JMJ or JAG site or if you yourself have a JMJ or
JAG site, please let Patty know - yours may be next to be
our Website of the Month.
Trivia Corner Last month our trivia challenge was to name the women who hold a special place in AJ's heart. How many of them did you come up with? They are: his sister Adele (Ghosts), Judge Laura Delaney (Ghosts), Marcella (Going After Francesca), Francesca (The Stalker and others), Sarah MacKenzie (several episodes), Harriet Sims (several episodes), Evelyn Clancy (With Intent to Die), and Shelly and Rachel Sherkston (Shakedown). Since last month we honored Mothers’ Day by naming the women who hold a place in his heart, this month we’ll honor Fathers. We have been introduced to some men who have played the role of mentor or father figure to AJ. Who are they? Again we’ll give you 1 point for each correct answer. To play
our trivia game, e-mail your answers to admiralslady@oocities.com by August 31. Answers will be
in the September issue of The Journal.
JMJAS Shirts!
From the Admiral's Desk This is our book review section, where we let you know about interesting JAG-related books, both fiction and nonfiction. A Guide to Military Criminal Law by Michael J. Davidson. I have not actually read this book as it is not yet out, but I do have it on order. It is described as a user-friendly reference for nonlawyers. Here is the write-up in the Naval Institute Press catalog. "Such pressing legal issues as sexual harassment and fraternization that face the U.S. military today make this reference essential reading for members of all the military services and for civilians with an interest in military law. The author is a former Army field artillery officer who has served as a military and federal prosecutor as well as a civilian litigation attorney specializing in discrimination cases. For this handy guide he explains the military justice system to the layman with useful and interesting discussions of military law and procedure. He illustrates legal points with famous cases and historical events, for example, the court-martial of baseball great Jackie Robinson. Particularly helpful are the comparisons he makes between the civilian and military legal systems. "The book includes an examination of nonjudicial punishment, a step-by-step description of the court-martial process, and an overview of the constitutional and statutory rights enjoyed by those in the military. It looks at selected military crimes and the defenses of such crimes. And, because war crimes committed by American service members are prosecuted under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the guide further provides an excellent introduction to the Law of War. "There is no other book currently available that presents such a complete yet easy-to-understand explanation for the nonlawyer of legal procedures in the military. A reader can find out about the jurisdiction of military law and who is subject to it—some will be surprised to learn that military retirees are covered by the laws—who makes up the court, what are considered to be crimes and examples of those who have been convicted, along with countless other facts that will prove useful to those seeking information on a unique segment of law in the United States." Sounds to me like a must for every JAG fan who wants to really understand just what it is our heroes do. Not to mention a must for every fanfic writer! Publication date is June 17; the list price is $27.95. The ISBN is 1-55750-155-6. It is available from the Naval Institute Press at 800-233-8764 or visit their website at http://www.usni.org. If you have read a JAG-related (in one
way or another) book that you think others might like,
please send your review to us at moviesii@aol.com.
The Jackson Vibe Earlier this year I posted a comment to the old quixotic list commenting on the increasing role the Admiral was playing in JAG episodes since he first started back in Season 1. I thanked TPTB for allowing us to see more of this fascinating character. Here is the reply from KIP35, a JAG Production insider: "As I'm sure you realize the real
thanks goes to John Jackson whose steady performances
make him a pleasure to write for in each episode. There's
sure to be much more of Admiral Chegwidden in the
remainder of this season and all the seasons to
come."
|
 (From "Soul Searching" - Season 4)
Welcome New Members We would like to extend a warm welcome to the following members who joined the fan club from May 1 through June 15:
Welcome
aboard! We add yet another new country this month --
Hungary--and we are now 183 strong and still growing.
We would like to wish a Very Happy Birthday and a joy-filled year to the following members with summer birthdays: June 2 - Vickie Rogus June 4 - Alison Holloway June 5 - Sharon Spolidora June 6 - Cathy Locks June 9 - Janice Walowski June 14 - Lisa Cox June 18 - Ellen June 22 - Kris Larsen June 23 - Timea Zsiga June 30 - Francesca Tucker July 1 - Wendy Bond July 1 - Wendy Joines July 7 - Charlotte LeJuez July 14 - Rebecca Bryce July 15 - Cosette23 August 2 - Traci Tatman August 5 - Cathy Edgely August 8 - Linda Campbell August 14 - Diane Rudesal August 28 - Yankee Rose
Meet Our Members My name is Brenda, and I live in Florida. I've enjoyed JAG as long as it's been on the air, but this past season has really made me take notice of Admiral Chegwidden. I always thought he was a handsome devil. After all, who can resist good-looking bald guy ala JMJ or Patrick Stewart. YUM! But the way this season has let us see more of his backstory is what really got my attention. I also should admit that I am in favor of Mac/AJ. The sexual tension between the two ... that almost kiss ... their trying to reach out with crossing the fraternization lines ... it all adds up to a sit-at-the-edge-of-your-seat- so-you-don't-miss-the-subtleties when Bell and Jackson have screen time together. I look forward to chatting with all of you about our favorite Admiral and show. **** Wow, what can I say so far but wow. It is amazing to find out that in this world there are others who are thinking the same things I am. Anyway I wanted to say hello to everyone and thank you all for allowing me to be part of such a wonderful list. I too am a fan of AJ. At first though I have to admit that I did want Harm and Mac to wind up together, but that was before I met the Admiral, so now every time Harm comes into the picture its like oh no, why did you have to come in right now things were just starting to get interesting. Ok well anyway my name is Jennifer, and I am a 21-year-old college student right now. I am currently attending school in California, but call Tennessee home. I am studying to be a Computer Animator/Computer Graphics Artist, and hope some day to work with a special effects house here in California. Ok well that is about all there is to know about me really. I must say that it is great to know that there is a support group out there so when I just get plain mad I can turn to you guys to back me up on the Mac/AJ thing. Ok well once again thanks for letting me be part of such a great group, can't wait to meet all of you. **** If you
would like to introduce yourself to the group, please
send a one-paragraph bio to Jenni at gypsy77@home.com. We'd love to get to know you.
Favorite Quotes: This month’s favorite quote comes from "The Game of Go." A Marine has been killed, and Harm, Bud, and Mac are being sent to Columbia to investigate. Admiral: Let me make this clear. Your assignment is to investigate what happened and nothing more. Mac: But the dead Marine, sir? Admiral: Retrieving bodies is not a JAG mission, Major. Mac: Sir, with all due respect . . . Admiral: But, if all you return with is
a report, consider your mission a failure.
As a
MEMBER-ONLY benefit, you can place an order through the
JMJAS for selected SEAL merchandise. Merchandise
available includes bumper stickers, SEAL Team 3 patches,
baseball caps, and a variety of t-shirts. The JMJAS makes
no profit on this merchandise - prices quoted are what we
pay. Please allow 6-8 weeks to receive merchandise. To
order SEAL Merchandise, please print out the order
form you'll find at that link, fill it out completely,
and mail it with your check or money order to the address
given. Be sure to include your e-mail address or phone
number (we will call collect) so we can contact you in
case of a question or problem with your order. Again,
this is a member-only benefit, so if you do not already
belong to the JMJAS, please join before placing an order. Thank
you.
Happy Birthday America!
|
FanFic Forum What If... by Jenni Martin Well, I have been writing reviews on stories others have written and felt it was time to do my own. "What If..." is a story that has been begging to be written since the episode "Stalker." I put my own twist on it letting Mac and AJ have a life without breaking all the rules. It is my interpretation of what I would like to see on the show. It brings them together and splits them up and keeps open all the possibilities of what is to come in the sequels "Easter Surprise," "How to Say Goodbye," and a yet untitled story I am working on. It is relatively short and sweet but it is pretty good. It is a nice story to read after you have had enough Harm/Mac stories... You will find this story in the FanFic Archives on the JMJAS site. About the Author What is your name? Jenni Martin Where are you from? San Diego, Ca What are your hobbies? Writing, Reading, and swimming. When did you start watching JAG? I have been watching since the beginning when I was pregnant with my son. Who is your favorite character? AJ and Mac What is your favorite episode? Ghosts When did you start writing Fan Fiction? Dec of 98 I started writing X-Files fan fiction and a couple of months later I started writing JAG. Do you write other types of Fan Fiction? I have been writing a Chronicle of sorts for X-Files, that has a mild crossover with JAG, and I have recently dabbled into a crossover with X-Files and Highlander. But I love JAG fiction. Which story that you have written is your favorite? How To Say Goodbye (Complete story) and Mustang Sarah (incomplete story) Which story that you have read is your
favorite? Suite Rowan by WinDay.
The Admiral's Briefing: We're going to bring you a complete list (in no particular order) of military abbreviations, so you'll know what the heck they're talking about on the show! I'll include this when I have space.
|
About
Fraternization Fraternization is one of the most complex, controversial, and misunderstood concepts in the United States military. It doesn’t help any that each branch of the military has different rules. Here is the United States Navy’s policy on fraternization as handed down by the Chief of Naval Operations in OPNAV Instructions 5370.2A dated March 14, 1994: "3. Policy. Personal relationships between officer and enlisted members that are unduly familiar and that do not respect differences in rank and grade are prohibited and violate long-standing custom and tradition of the naval service. Similar relationships that are unduly familiar between officers or between enlisted members of different rank or grade may also be prejudicial to good order and discipline or of a nature to bring discredit on the naval service and are prohibited." Most of the trouble stems from the "unduly familiar" and "do not respect differences in rank and grade" provisions of this rule. In actual fact, some forms of fraternization are not only acceptable but desirable. Fraternization, which means strictly "to associate in a brotherly manner; be on friendly terms," is necessary if units are to build teamwork, and proper social interaction among officer and enlisted members has always been encouraged as it enhances unit morale and esprit de corps. But there is a fine line between what is acceptable and necessary and what is "too" familiar. Vice Admiral Dennis Blair, Director of the Joint Staff, explained it like this during a July 29 Pentagon briefing. "’You’ve got a division on a ship – men, women, chiefs, officers, some mixtures of each,’ he said. ‘You’re going to have a division softball game, so you all go out in the afternoon and you play.’ The teams are mixed, Blair said, and all are having a good time. This is acceptable fraternization. ‘The game’s over and now you bring out a couple of cases of beer and you have the after-game party. Everybody is there, full daylight [and they’re saying] ‘We won,’ ‘You lost,’ ‘I beat you,’ ‘I struck you out.’ This is also acceptable fraternization. But if the party continues and breaks into smaller groups heading to different destinations, then those involved ought to start thinking about what the fraternization policy allows. For example, an officer asking an enlisted person out for a drink is not allowed, Blair said." Although the term "fraternization" is most commonly applied to officer-enlisted relationships, fraternization also includes improper relationships and social interaction between officers as well as between enlisted members. It is also a gender-neutral concept, meaning that many people have the mistaken notion that fraternization can only occur between a man and a woman in a "romantic" situation. In fact, it can be, as stated above, something as simple as a male officer inviting an enlisted man to go have a beer or play poker. OPNAV Instruction 5370.2A explains the background of the fraternization policy like this: "Over 200 years of seagoing experience have demonstrated that seniors must maintain thoroughly professional relationships with juniors at all times. This custom recognizes the need to prevent use of a senior grade or position in such a way that it results in (or gives the appearance of) favoritism, preferential treatment, personal gain, or involves actions that otherwise may reasonably be expected to undermine good order, discipline, authority, or high unit morale. In like manner, custom requires that junior personnel recognize and respect the authority inherent in a senior’s grade, rank, or position. This recognition of authority is evidenced by observance and enforcement of the military courtesies and customs that have traditionally defined proper senior-subordinate relationships." In short, bosses are bosses and the people working for them must understand that. Bosses - whether senior enlisted or officer - must not only *be* impartial, they must be *perceived* by service members as being impartial. In "The Rules of Engagement," author David Van Biema says that "Today commanders face nightmare scenarios of officers using rank to extort sex, of favoritism and jealousy eating away at the chain of command and hard-won troop morale, of subordinates wondering if their officer sent them on a particularly dangerous mission to avoid assigning it to a lover." Vice Admiral Blair said, "Our superiors in the armed forces have incredible authority over their subordinates. In war, they send them out to die. In peacetime, the superior’s decisions make the difference between professional success and failure in each of our service member's careers." He went on to point out that actual or perceived favoritism can corrode unit morale and standards must be applied fairly or teamwork in the unit will break down. "Fraternization" is a uniquely military concept. Although management problems are certainly created in a civilian organization when someone abuses their position for personal gain, in the context of military life, the erosion of respect for the authority and leadership position of a senior that occurs can have an enormous and negative effect on "good order and discipline" which then undermines a unit’s effectiveness. So the military believes its policies against fraternization serve a valid purpose essential to the mission of the military. Here is the section of OPNAV Instruction 5370.2A that specifies prohibited relationships: "5. Prohibited Relationships.
As the Instruction says, "It is impossible to set forth every act that may be prejudicial to good order and discipline or that is service-discrediting because the surrounding circumstances often determine whether the conduct in question is inappropriate. Proper social interactions and appropriate personal relationships are an important part of unit morale and esprit de corps. Officer and enlisted participation on command sports teams and other command-sponsored events intended to build unit morale and camaraderie are healthy and clearly appropriate. Dating, cohabitation, and intimate or sexual relations between officers and enlisted members are unduly familiar and are prohibited, as would be a private business partnership between officer and enlisted members. Likewise, such conduct between officer members and between enlisted members of different rank or grade would be unduly familiar and constitute fraternization if the conduct is prejudicial to good order and discipline or is service discrediting." The Instruction goes on to state that prejudice to good order and discipline or discredit to the service occurs when the familiarity between a senior and a subordinate is such that the senior’s objectivity can be questioned. Such a loss of objectivity can result in actual or perceived preferential treatment of the subordinate. It can result in the actual or perceived use of the senior’s position for the gain of the subordinate. It undermines the senior’s leadership authority when it gives rise to the perception that the senior is no longer capable of or willing to exercise fairness and make decisions based on merit. In the case of fraternization, perception is reality. If a senior is perceived as not being impartial, his or her leadership authority is undermined, and the chain of command is compromised. [Note: chain of command is defined as "where there is a direct senior-subordinate relationship."] As should have been made clear by now, fraternization is not limited to those in the same chain of command - unduly familiar relationships may exist outside a person’s direct chain of command. Several are specifically referred to in the Instructions: relationships between Chief Petty Officers and junior personnel, between instructors and trainees within Navy training commands, and between recruiters and recruits. However, the fact that individuals are within the same chain of command increases the likelihood that an unduly familiar relationship will result in "prejudice to good order and discipline or discredit to the naval service." It goes back to the circumstances surrounding the actions. One other thing that should be clear by now is that fraternization can only occur when you have service personnel of differing ranks. It applies strictly to a senior-subordinate relationship. In short, we finally have a definitive answer to the question of whether a Harm/Mac relationship would run afoul of fraternization rules. It would not as their ranks are equal. It is interesting to note that the policy on fraternization specifically includes service members who are married or otherwise related to other service members (father/son, etc.). There is no leeway given for familial relationships; they "must maintain the requisite respect and decorum attending the official relationship while either is on duty or in uniform in public." In order to avoid any appearance of fraternization which might be detrimental to the morale of a unit, "service members married to each other will not be assigned in the same chain of command" subject to compatibility with sea/shore rotation policy and the needs of the service. Lastly, the Instruction states, "The responsibility for preventing inappropriate relationships must rest primarily on the senior. While the senior party is expected to control and preclude the development of inappropriate relationships, this policy is applicable to both members and both are accountable for their own conduct." What this typically translates into is that while the junior in the relationship might receive friendly counseling or an informal warning, the senior might receive a fine, reprimand, demotion or court-martial under the UCMJ at the discretion of the commanding officer. Because of this, Defense Secretary William Cohen last year ordered the armed services to be more uniform but harsher in their treatment of fraternization while still handling it at the lowest appropriate level—i.e., punishment or counseling within a company as opposed to a court martial. One final note: fraternization can also
occur when the individuals belong to different military
services. It all goes back to whether the differences in
rank and grade are respected or whether they can be seen
to be prejudicial to good order and discipline or of a
nature to bring discredit to the Navy.
|
| The
Admiral's Mast In this feature, you - the viewer - get to be the critic. We invite you to review the JAG episodes and give them two ratings - one for the overall episode and one for the episode as a showcase for JMJ. Please rank them based on a system of 1-10 where 10 is the best. You can review every episode or just your favorites. You can write two sentences or two paragraphs or two pages. You can write about the plot (although you do not need to summarize the plot as we will have seen the episodes ourselves), the special effects, the acting, "bloopers," whatever aspect appeals to you. But do write! This is truly a case of "the more the merrier." This column is being compiled by HughesFan so send your reviews to HughesFan@aol.com. The subject line should read "JAG/JMJ Review." Please do not put anything else in the reference line. The rules are a little bit different this time around. Since we will not have another new Journal until the September issue, and since there will be no new JAG episodes before then, we invite you to submit a review of your favorite Season 1-3 JAG episode (only caveat - AJ must appear in more than the opening credits). We will publish those reviews in our September issue, then pick up in October with our reviews of new Season 5 episodes that air in September. |
|
 |
Second Sight (aired April 27, 1999) |
| Review by Gray
Cargill: Ratings: JAG: 9 AJ: 5 I have nothing but praise for Dana Coen for this outstanding episode. It was truly a lovely script. I wish every episode was this good. I also have nothing but praise for Catherine Bell for her awesome performance in this episode. I think this was an even better episode than The Stalker in terms of being a showcase for her acting abilities (although I'll always have a soft spot in my heart for The Stalker). Every one of Mac's reactions to the situation from start to finish rang really true to me. I can't recall the director's name--looked like a new guy?--but he also did an outstanding job with direction. The candles lighting up the JAG Office, the slow-mo scene when Mac first entered the hospice, the scene where her father squeezed her hand right before he died--all very nice. The casting of Mac's parents could have been better. No offense to Conchata Ferrell, whose acting I thought was terrific as always, but neither one of the actors playing her parents looked remotely like her. Is Mac adopted or something? (I'm being flip. I don't really think she's adopted.) Michael Tucci was fabulous as the priest. I liked him tremendously. I was a little angry at Mac for blasting him the way she did (when she called him a "wimp")--that was pretty harsh way to treat such a nice guy, but also a very human response. They had some lovely interactions. I so loved the exchange about the "tormented soul"--she assumes he's talking about her father, but he's really talking about her. Great stuff. I was extremely grateful that Dana Coen didn't feel the need to demonize Mac's mother in order to paint the father as a good guy. It was all very subtle and Conchata Ferrell's performance was nicely understated. I guess it was Nancy who complained that she thought that Mac's turnaround regarding her mother was a little sudden or harsh or something. I, too, will need to go back and watch the episode a second time before coming to any final conclusions, but I felt that it was actually very well done. I didn't get the impression that Mac was deciding her mother was the villain and her father the victim, but rather that she was seeing them both clearly for the first time ever. All her life, she demonized her father, while putting her mother up on a pedestal. (Although HOW she could put a woman on a pedestal who abandoned her is beyond me.) Well, now she knows it wasn't as clearcut as all that. I believe her mother did topple off that pedestal she had her on, but I don't think she blames her mother more than her father; rather, I think she's come to the (very mature, I might add) conclusion that they both made mistakes, they were both weak and pathetic in their own ways, that they didn't do things right by her, but that they're not evil and never intended to hurt her. They were just failures as parents. I was stunned to see so little of the Harm storyline in this episode; that so rarely happens. Not that I'm complaining; I'm glad to see someone else take center stage for a change. I agree with you, Nancy, I was really pleased with Harm's portrayal in this episode, especially in the way he treated Mac--and especially when he didn't turn the subject to his own problem, even when he had the opening. After she said "this isn't like you and your father," he could have responded with "No, I just found out my night blindness was misdiagnosed." It was good of him not to turn the subject to his own problem, I thought. Let's face it, if this had happened a few months ago, he probably would have. So, it's nice to see some growth going on here. If I had been him, though, I'd have been very upset that my night blindness had been misdiagnosed. Being a pilot was everything to him and he had to give it up. To then later learn that he really didn't have to give it up after all, that he'd just been misdiagnosed--wow, what a blow. But it would also make me think long and hard about issues of fate and destiny and stuff like that. Maybe he really was meant to be a JAG lawyer instead of a pilot and the only way to drag him out of the cockpit was by having his vision problem misdiagnosed? Of course, that presumes divine intervention. I imagine we'll see more of this in the next few weeks. Finally, the JAG Office part of the storyline. Like most others, I was pleased to see more of Tiner and I'll take as much of AJ as the writers will give me, but I really saw this part of the storyline as the weak link in an otherwise powerful episode. That's not necessarily a bad thing. An episode as emotionally wrenching as this one needs some lighter moments to offset the really heavy ones, and it's obvious that's the purpose this segment served. And good for Dana to be able to link it to the "sight" theme of the episode. I did also dig the scene where AJ asked if he was going soft. I think sometimes he is, but I'd never dare say so to his face. Frankly, I think that was a trick question. :-) One thing was missing from this episode, and I've already had 2 people email me today to ask if my next MIA story will be that scene we should have seen where Mac goes to the Admiral to request leave to visit her dying father. You betcha! :-) Review by Kelly: Ratings: JAG: 7 AJ: 8 (and great exasperation!) I've seen some comments and complaints that CB hasn't really had a GOOD central storyline this season. I think this episode certainly qualifies. I'm not much of a Mac fan- and certainly haven't been too happy with where the character's been taken this year-but I thought this episode was great. Anytime you have a "dysfunctional" upbringing you end up carrying around a LOT of baggage...Mac's shown that before (through the alcoholism, the distancing herself, the bad choices with men etc.) but this week we finally got a chance to see how it's affected whatever small chance she had of working things out with her parents. The one line she had (and I'm paraphrasing) about she coped with it, and got past it by basically walking away.....that's something that CB brought across as (the way I saw it) being ambivalent about....she did it, and she's moved on, but I got the impression that in some small little corner of her heart she was still hoping for some kind of resolution; and when the priest brought it up, she went after him (don't the Marines teach that the best defense is a good offense? *s*) I thought the writers made it very real by making it impossible for her to make peace directly with her father- real life doesn't always work out, and it was nice to see them not wrap it all up in a bow. I loved the priest, he did a fabulous job (and wonderful casting, that wasn't an easy role) The scenes with her mother (and I'm a big fan of Ms. Ferrell) were great...the way she worried about how she looked, what Mac thought of her.....I felt sorry for her in the first set of scenes.....then after Joe died, and Mac was talking with her...you could see how Mac reacted.....maybe finally coming to terms with the fact that Joe was a rotten father, and a drunk...but that "in his own sorry way, he did the best he could" and how her mother's actions looked from that POV.... I loved this storyline. Harm's eye test.......well, at least we got a reasonable explanation for the night-blindness issue *wry laugh* I'm not sure I like the way this storyline is going, but that's right now, and hopefully will change. The "technology issue" and the video conferencing etc.....LOVED IT!!!!! Especially actually seeing scenes with Tiner...and finding out a little about him (studying electronics at junior college) JMJ and PL were great (and so was Chuck Carrington, who we don't see enough of IMHO) and the storyline was a nice contrast to the other two. Now onto my one major peeve.....I HATED the last scene.....ENOUGH with the pregnancy cliches! When Harriet dropped the flashlight I almost walked out of the room in disgust.....we all know (or at least really think we do) that the baby episode is right before the season finale (and I have to tape the baby one, cause I'll be "camping out" that night) so what was the point in having us see her fall--or almost fall....I was completely disgusted with the scene and I actually came right out and said "what was the point of that" That scene marred one of the (again, IMHO) best written and acted episodes of the season. Review by Lyn: JAG: 9 AJ: 8 First off, I should probably start by saying that I *loved* Harm in this episode. Finally seemed more like the Harm we'd come to know and love - the one who used to be there for Mac all the time but had gotten lax about it lately. I thought the little scene where she says it's not a good time and he walks away and comes right back - how about now? - was great. I laughed, but he was so right not to let it go. And that was good advice he gave her. I thought the whole thing with his eyes was pretty well done, although I was surprised he had no real reaction to being told he'd been misdiagnosed. I would have expected him to be angry about it. After all, he'd lost all that time perhaps for nothing. The doctor didn't really say how long that treatment had been available, so maybe he would have lost the time anyway - it wasn't really clear to me. I think one of the best lines of the night was when the doctor told Harm, "No one can fault you for trying to complete the dream." A very wise man. Too bad Mac wasn't there to hear it! <vbg> The whole storyline with Mac was very interesting. I thought it was very effective that she never got a chance to actually talk to her father but that she found all that stuff out via the priest. I'm not familiar with the guy who played the priest, but I thought he was wonderful. CB was great, but I'm not really sure how I feel about the way they ended that. I'll have to watch it some more, but it seemed a little odd to me - almost a little too pat. It was nice that Mac was able to come to terms with the fact that her father was a flawed and even pathetic human being but he did love her nevertheless and did the best he could, even though his best was not very good at all. Also thought it was realistic that she and her mother would have very different reactions to Joe's passing. There's a special bond that forms between children and parents, even when they're not good parents, that is not equalled between a man and a woman. Love dies between a man and a woman, but even people who ostensibly hate their parents still want and need their parents' love and approval, even though they keep saying they don't care. There's nothing else quite like it. What I'm not quite sure about is Mac's sudden reversal in attitude toward her mother. It would be one thing if her mother had left when she was quite young (which is what I had originally thought), but she stuck it out until Mac was 15 before leaving. She made it through most of Mac's childhood. While her mother is not a particularly sympathetic character, neither did I find her to be unsympathetic either. When she finally left after fearing for her life, I can understand somewhat her leaving Mac behind. She had no place to go and no plan for what she was going to do when she got there. And she obviously believed that Mac would be taken care of by Joe while she herself had no way of knowing if she'd be able to take care of Mac herself. Certainly not an admirable choice but somewhat understandable--and in retrospect it would appear to have been the right one. But it was nice to have some light shed on Mac's background. Now if we can just find out some more about her early Marine career and how she got so far so fast!! <g> What can I say about AJ? Loved that
whole thing, especially the part where he's worried he's
getting soft. <lol> OFA was certainly *not* having
a good day, was he. Love the facial expressions and body
language JMJ uses with him - you just know he's trying to
keep a lid on his temper and not having an easy time of
it. <g> Only reason his rating was an 8 was that he
did not have that much to do in this episode. Nice to see
Tiner doing something substantial for a change. I don't
think he's had that much to do since "Secrets."
His whole interaction with AJ was just great. Hope for
his sake OFA never finds out what "really"
happened to the power at JAG! :)
|
|
 |
Wilderness of Mirrors (aired May 4, 1999) |
| Review by Gray Cargill: Ratings: JAG: 7 AJ: 9 This episode features the return of Clark Palmer and his diabolical machinations to keep Harm trapped in a "wilderness of mirrors"--a "state of extreme paranoia experienced by spooks and spies who have been in the business too long," as we learned in "Webb of Lies." How appropriate, therefore, that the episode was filled with mirror images and reflections of Harm, Sr. as well as the mirror used by Palmer in the climax. You can't say Palmer doesn't have a sense of humor. I also appreciated the fake name he assumed in this episode, "Lt. Maggio" ("maggio" meaning "magician"). Magicians are well known for using "smoke and mirrors" to perform their illusions. I really enjoyed the direction of this episode (by Alan J. Levi); the ever-present thunderstorm with the driving rain underscored the eerie plot of the A storyline. While predictable, the A storyline was still enjoyable. (Is Paul Levine a new writer? I don't recall seeing his name in the credits before. If so, good job.) It was fun seeing Harm get gaslighted by Palmer, and I think David James Elliott did quite credibly with Harm's vulnerability about whether or not he was going crazy. I was happy to see the writers portray Jordan as an intelligent and resourceful woman here, a capable psychiatrist, a caring girlfriend, and no helpless female. Even after Palmer had her bound and gagged, she didn't just sit idly by and wait for Harm to rescue her--she did everything she could to warn him about Palmer's trap by inching her chair forward and jiggling the mirror with her foot. Smart. I appreciated her subtle suspicion when "Maggio" suddenly showed up looking for her at Harm's apartment ("How did you find me?" would have been the first question I asked, too), although she seemed too easily persuaded by his story about calling her service. It's high time we got to see Harm and Jordan working as a team--in this case, to get to the bottom of Palmer's scheme. Jordan's suggestion to try star-69 was, as Harm said, brilliant. I can understand Harm guessing that "Maggio" was really Palmer--it was a little too coincidental that Jordan was treating someone with an identical situation to Harm's own--but what made him think "Maggio's" tale of abandonment was real and not fabricated? It seems a little careless to me that Palmer would include actual details from his own life in his discussions with Jordan when everything else about his plan was so well thought out. And, as has been mentioned by others, I was surprised that, as often as Harm listens to his father's tapes, he failed to recognize a verbatim quote lifted from one of his favorites. Palmer's plan was both brilliant and diabolical: Place Harm's bound and gagged girlfriend behind a mirror angled so Harm thinks he's shooting Palmer when he's really shooting his own girlfriend. (Harm: "If you've hurt her in any way--" Palmer: "Oh no. I thought I'd leave that up to you.") Heh heh heh. Evil, man. If his plan had worked, Harm would have become a tragic character of Byronic proportions. Try living with that guilt. I don't blame Harm for accompanying Palmer to Leavenworth; after what happened last time, there's nothing paranoid about that! If that paper clip means anything, I'd guess we haven't seen the last of ol' Clark. Good. The B storyline involving A.J.'s preparations for his appearance before the Supreme Court had absolutely nothing to do with the title of the episode, but what the heck. It was still great. It's rare that we are allowed to see the Admiral feeling insecure, so I was genuinely feeling for him during the scene at his home where he's preparing his speech and none of his attempts are very good. The role reversal between Bud and A.J. during the moot court preparation was great fun. Bud really put A.J. through his paces. I actually felt sorry for the Admiral. It didn't look like he was doing all that well with his argument for a while there. Question: Were the cases he cited in his argument actual cases from real life, or were they fabricated for the purposes of the story? I had no idea what was going on in this scene. A.J. cited a couple of cases, Mac, Brumby, and Bud looked suitably impressed, and voila! They rule in his favor. Perhaps a bit more explanation for us non-lawyers in the audience next time? Mac is served well in this episode, dispensing sound advice to Harm--especially in regards to his relationship with Jordan (it's nice to see a woman show loyalty to a member of her own gender)--and showing concern and compassion for the Admiral when his case was dropped. I assume anyone could have delivered the message to him; Mac must have volunteered, knowing how crushed he would be. I really felt the Admiral's disappointment when he realized he wouldn't be arguing in front of the Supreme Court. I almost cringed when Mac started to say "If it's any consolation--" No, Mac, it isn't. Kip reported that this scene was one of "subtle electricity" between A.J. and Mac which goes unacknowledged by both of them. Uh-huh. Good thing he told me, 'cause that electricity was so damn subtle, even I missed it--and I have the keenest Mac/AJ radar of anyone I know. Next time, I recommend a less subtle approach. ;-) It was a lovely, sweet, and touching scene, however--enjoyable even without electricity. I had wondered what their relationship was like after her Admiral's Mast, since we hadn't seen any interaction between just the two of them since then. I wasn't sure if she was still in his doghouse or not. I guess not. On the bright side, A.J. actually thanked Mac to her face this time. (There you go, Sandy B.! I know, I know, it doesn't make up for the oversight in "Going After Francesca," but it's a start.) Miscellaneous: It's too bad the unwarranted harsh criticism of Brumby's character last fall has resulted in the writers watering down his character. At this point, he doesn't seem to have much personality left. What a shame. JMJ was certainly looking pretty buff in that scene where Mac showed up at his door. Been working out much? I laughed out loud at the look the maid gave Harm when he burst in on her with his gun. It was a world-weary expression of a woman who sees that sort of thing all the time and is not amused by it. Kinda makes you wonder about those DC hotels, doesn't it? Favorite Quotes: Mac: My social life is flying so low it wouldn't be picked up by radar.
Review by Lyn: JAG: 8 AJ: 9 I really liked this episode--there was much that was good about it and very little that I didn't like. It was great to see Harm being cordial to Brumby for a change - their interactions were funny, but they always did make Harm seem just a *little* childish. So to have him greet Brumby politely and ask about his vacation was a nice touch - Harm is growing up. <g> I really liked Brumby too. I usually do, although there have been "moments," but I thought he seems to be settling in nicely to the group. Loved the look he gave Mac when she said her social life was flying so low it wouldn't be picked up on radar. And finally finally finally we got to see Harm and Jordan interact for a change. What a treat! I have always liked Jordan, and I liked her even more after this episode. She's smart and funny and warm and caring and very very human. I liked that she tried to help Harm to the best of her ability. Her reactions and her concern for him rang very true. Very smart to think of the *69 and very smart to mention involving the police. And when Harm was not inclined to get any help, she recognized his need to do this himself and let him go without fu rther complaint. I loved that she was so level-headed after Palmer got her. She didn't panic or get hysterical - she tried to help herself and Harm by nudging the mylar. Good job! So why do I have this sinking feeling that she won't be around much longer? I was a little surprised at the bit with the tapes, though - that was probably my biggest gripe about the whole episode, which is really not much of a gripe. <g> If Harm plays those tapes so much, why didn't he notice the first time Palmer called him and he went to listen to his father's tapes that the tapes were out of order. Since Palmer obviously had the equipment, why did he not change that message about the bat rather than play it verbatim? If it's one of Harm's favorites, why did he not recognize it immediately? Nitpicks really. Mac was very well served here. You have got to love her consideration of Jordan, which was evident throughout this whole episode. Having been alerted to the fact that Jordan has concerns about her relationship with Harm, she went to great lengths to be on Jordan's side--letting the Admiral know Harm had plans with her, encouraging Harm (and she was absolutely right too) to talk to Jordan about what was happening, and telling Harm not to let Jordan know she'd talked to her first. Bravo, Mac! I thought the whole subplot with the Admiral arguing before the Supreme Court was great. He may not have cared much for the "monkey suit," but boy did he look handsome! <g> I really liked that he turned to the others for help in getting ready. Many in that position would have let their ego go to their heads and just assumed that since they were the JAG, they were up for anything. It was a nice look into hismore "vulnerable" side that we got to see his nervousness and uncertainty. Yet we still know from watching him that he was a very formidable lawyer in his day--and very smart in the way he prepared himself. Anyone else want to choke the SECNAV for even thinking for so much as a second that AJ was not up to the challenge? Anyone else feel their heart breaking when he lost his chance to go before the Supreme Court? I loved that scene between Mac and AJ at the house. He was like a little kid contemplating a special treat - he was so excited at getting a chance to argue this case. And so very disappointed when it was taken away from him. There are so very few lawyers who get a chance to argue before the Supreme Court, and I know what a thrill it is to see the opinion written up, even when you lose. So my heart just broke for AJ - I *really* wanted him to have his moment in the sun. And such a typical reaction to the disappointment in not wanting to hear the platitudes that Mac was going to utter. A couple of times there I really expected Mac to put her arm around his shoulders to give him a hug--I think I would have if I'd been there. Mac's departing line about how they were "all very proud of you" obviously touched him though. That was nice - not much consolation, though. All in all, a very nice episode..
|
|
 |
Soul Searching (aired May 11, 1999) |
| Review by Gray Cargill: Ratings: JAG: 9 AJ: 10 What a treat! Not only is this the first episode written by Donald Bellisario since "Gypsy Eyes," but the A storyline focuses on two of the most interesting JAG characters, A.J. and Webb. There is very little, if anything, to criticize about the A storyline. It was a gem. The B storyline left a lot to be desired, but perhaps that's because I'm not a man and don't understand the obsessive love men have for their automobiles. Director Jeannot Szwarc does a very nice job here. I particularly enjoyed the lighting of many of the scenes, including the teaser, and the flashbacks Webb has of Tim Fox's kidnapping. The mission undertaken by A.J. and Webb to rescue the man (Tim Fox) who means so much to both of them was fabulous, from start to finish. I found Webb to be at his most likable in this episode. It was impressive that he cared enough about Fox that he would work without Company approval to try to rescue him, and that he would come to the Admiral for help when his initial attempt failed. Frankly, I didn't think he had it in him. The character of George Decker seemed pointless at first, but then I began to wonder: Was his shallow and boorish portrayal supposed to point out just how much Webb has grown as a human being over the past few years? If so, it worked. The George Decker of this episode made me think that this is what Webb would have been like if he hadn't been introduced to the JAG crew in "We, The People." You've come a long way, baby. However, it makes me very nervous to think the CIA hired a dufus like Decker. Good grief, if he can get a job with the CIA, anybody can. That's a scary thought. I was glad to see some follow-up to the events of "Going After Francesca" here. What are the odds that Amanti, the mobster, would be Luscino Antinori's uncle? It's interesting to learn that the "official" story is that A.J., not Francesca, killed Luscino. That would explain why the Mafia hasn't tried to retaliate against Francesca. Smart. Given that the Camorra operates in Naples, and the Mafia in Sicily (and that Marcella is Sicilian), I assume that would mean that the Parettis were Mafia? I also got the impression that so were the Antinoris (when Amanti says "Only the Camorra use their women to kill" or something like that). But why did Webb feel the need to explain the difference between the Mafia and the Camorra to A.J., who already knew all about them? Answer: Webb was explaining the difference to us, the audience, not to A.J. While I was glad to be educated on the subject, I would have preferred it not to be in such a forced exposition. I know I'm probably alone on this one, but I really despised the "Mine's bigger" line from A.J. First, it was unnecessary: The visual image of his gun, sitting next to Webb's smaller gun on the tray, said it all. (Unless, of course, Bellisario doesn't trust the intelligence of his viewers to "get it.") Second, it was petty and beneath A.J. to make such a statement. He has never felt the need for such macho posturing before. Why start now? I very much enjoyed A.J.'s attitude during his conversation with Amanti. It's not often we see this dangerous edge to him--anger we see frequently, but this was different. This was a quiet deadliness, a matter-of-fact attitude about having to kill people that radiates far more danger than an explosion of anger ever could: A.J.: Senior Amanti, many people have tried to kill me at one time or another. They're mostly dead. So there's a good chance that your brother-in-law will join them if he comes after me. Does he have other sons? Amanti: Uno. A.J.: When he comes, I'll regrettably kill him, too. And after him? Amanti: My sister will expect me to uphold the honor of la familia. A.J.: Then I'll have to kill you. I don't want to have to do that. Brr. Chilling. (Reminds me of many of the villains JMJ has played during his career.) Yet, this is the same man who has that cute moment with the children at the fountain who are scooping up the change: "Stealing other people's wishes stunts your growth." Adorable. Is there any other character on JAG who is this well-rounded and complex? I think not--with the possible exception of his cohort in this episode, Webb. The moment on the rooftop when A.J. reveals to Webb just how Tim saved his soul was quite moving. I was surprised, though, that Webb didn't understand that A.J. had answered his question. Of course he would have taken the shot--because he was "young and believed in carrying out his mission above all else." But he would have carried the guilt of killing a nun for the rest of his life. That's how Tim saved his soul. A.J.'s plan to get Tim to use baseball terminology to let them know the locations of the two terrorists so they could kill them was ingenious. There was great tension in that scene, great buildup, and then it all happened so fast, it was hard to believe it was over--just as I'm sure such a scenario would play out in real life. The only thing this final scene lacked for me was a reaction on Webb's part to having made his first "kill"--especially because it was a woman. That couldn't have been easy, no matter who she was or what she was guilty of. The B storyline, involving cars--the theft of Harm's classic 'vette and Bud and Harriet's purchase of a minivan in preparation for the arrival of the baby--was less engaging. I did, however, find Harm's phone call to the emergency hotline funny in a perverse sort of way. The same thing has happened to me so many times, I found it all too true-to-life. I loved the discussion between Bud and Harm about the structural damage caused by Harm firing a weapon in the courtroom two years ago. Talk about an eye-opening lesson about the consequences of his actions. Poor Harm really doesn't live in reality, does he? In "Nobody's Child," he found it unbelievable that a parent wouldn't notice that their child had been missing for over 24 hours, and here, we learn he has been parking a classic car on the street, in full view of car thieves, without a police tracking system. Did he grow up at Disneyland or something? Such faith in his fellow human beings is touching, but extremely naive. And just when you think Harm might be starting to grow up, he reassures you that he's still an unenlightened male by making a remark like: "Mac, you pick out a new car with your girlfriend, you might as well buy her a ring." It's nice to know some things will never change. On the continuity front, I was also pleased to see mention of the death of Mac's father and her reunion with her mother. I'm glad to see the events of one episode don't operate in a vacuum. But does anyone know why Mac walked up to the "remains" of Harm's 'vette and smiled? That seemed like an odd reaction to me, particularly since she knew how devastated he was about it. The final scene, with Mac driving up in the sports car, also did nothing for me. It seemed a little too forced and "cute". The real ending of this episode, in my opinion, was the scene with A.J., Webb, Tim, and Decker in the piazza. Favorite Quotes:
Review by Kelly: Ratings: JAG: 10 AJ: 11 HOLY COW!!!! I'm still so jazzed over this episode I'm not sure where to start...... First of all, any episode that has Webb in the very first scene is going to be a good one for me...that said; it looks like he might have learned a lesson about trying to do something on his own. Initially he tried to rescue (Tom?) with the help of the Italian authorities, then once that failed, he went to the one place he was sure he would get help...AJ. We also learned a bit more about Clay again and my personal conclusion is that the ending will be spawning some interesting fic in the near future. As usual, I loved Steven Culp.....he plays Webb in a way that's earnest and appealing...the only possible complaint I have is that we don't see enough of him (and I can only hope we see more of him next season!) JMJ was fabulous as always. Watching him interact with the Mafia Don was a lot of fun......he knew going in that this guy would give him trouble, but nothing was going to stop him from trying to rescue the man who "saved his soul" all those years ago. There's always something of a sizzle when JMJ and SC share a scene, and all their scenes tonight were great.....in their own way, they have as much chemistry playing off each other as DJE and CB do. The look on SC's face after the "Mine's bigger" comment.......I was laughing so hard I had tears falling! The way the rescue was set up, cueing Tom to AJ's presence, as well as allowing him to contribute to his own rescue....loved it. Having Clay be the one to take out the woman; giving him the opportunity to "redeem" himself, in his own mind at least, for freezing during the initial kidnapping.....at the same time, sharing the fact that this was his first kill....knowing that in some way, off-screen if not on, that Clay will have to come to terms with that....both the action itself as well as it being a woman. The sharing of a common goal between Clay and AJ, in some ways diffusing the hostility (hopefully) gives DPB a lot of room to play with for next season with these two "supporting" characters. The "B" plot was a nice, light contrast. I loved the comment about Harm's sexuality being defined by his car, even more so that Mac was comfortable enough to tease him about it! I also liked what little we saw of the detective; I wouldn't mind seeing more of him *g* This episode was a lot of fun to watch, and I'll certainly enjoy watching it over and over. The jokes and gag lines made me laugh, and the action kept the pace quick. Overall I'd say a wonderful episode.....now if only we can have more Webb and AJ next year!! Review by Pat Murray: Ratings: JAG: 8.5 (7 from the East German Judge) AJ: 8.5 Harriet: 10 Webb: 7.75 First things first- Drop Bugme and add more Harriet! <VBG> Whenever I see Brumby, I always think of my revised ad copy for Foster's beer-Brumby: Australian for crap! Granted, I do not know the Aussies like other here, but I know not all people from Down Under talk like Crocodile Dundee! Maybe on his last ep, Harm will finally deck him. Nah. Mac or Harriet will!! I'm sure Harriet can launch a helluva punch. For any man who still think pregnancy is not pretty, let me refer to Karri Turner. She may not really be preggers, but she pulls it of well and damn, sexy too! <VBG> And you thought Cindy Crawford made pregnancy sexy! Obviously, Cindy took lessons from Karri!!! <VBG> For once, I actually liked Webb in this one. But, rest assured, I am not going to be defect into a Webbie. One ep makes not a Webbie me. Webb, showed he actually felt guilty about doing nothing (twice, really once the first time and the second was when was hit by grenade shrapnel) in the Fox situation. In broad daylight, anyone could have seen AJ's scope reflect the sunlight as he put the crosshairs on the target. One could easily see AJ was not the sniper on his SEAL fire team in the jungles of Vietnam. The baseball code is very reminiscent of the film "BAT 21" starring Gene Hackman and Danny Glover. Damn good film based on a true (if incomplete) story. But, I digress. It was good to see Webb see his victim as a terrorist and a target, rather than just a good looking woman. I had mixed feelings about the opening bit with Harm reporting to the cops about his stolen "baby". I do sympathize with Harm, though. One time, some jerks broke into my car (a used '66 Corvair) and stole the tape deck and all of my tapes. What hurt me the most was most of the tapes I made myself. Songs I got off the radio and taped and my own various compilation tapes of my favorite songs. Tragic. The police help line is very VERY reminiscent of customer support lines. Any one who had called any kind of tech support knows this. But as a tech support agent, I was a bit miffed at the recordings. I know it was a joke and not meant to be taken seriously, but still. I can honestly say, I have never been attached to a car like Harm and Bud. To computers, yes, but not a car! I do see the part about fond memories of them, though. Okay, we have seen every character on JAG at or use a computer except one--Harriet!!!! Even AJ!!! Surely, Harriet has learned SOMETHING of computers living with Bud. And I am not talking about his bookmarked Star Trek or Quantum Leap sites. I loved Mac's face when she pulled up in a 'Vette, though! Classic!! Kinda like "where have you been my whole life?" attitude. Overall, I thought this was a great ep, even if it did have to have Webb. Can't wait for next week, though!!! More Harriet!!! Yoo hoo!!!! This lad be a happy camper! On an off topic note, I was reading the paper today and in the entertainment section, they had an article on Isaac Hayes, known to kids today as "Chef" on South Park. In it, he said his character actually charmed "Kathie Lee Gifford" into bed on the cartoon. As we all know how gave SP's KLG her voice, right? Karri Turner!! Hmm. Which got me thinking (scary thought, I know) <sung to the tune of SHAFT by Isaac Hayes>
Okay. I have too much time thinking on the buses to work. Review by Lyn: JAG: 10 AJ: 10 WOW!! That was one terrific episode and goes right up there near the top (if not at the top) of the list of my all-time favorite JAG episodes. I have to say that IMHO this was a *much* better Webb episode than "Webb of Lies." I thought this episode was dead-on as far as Webb's character goes. The portrayal of him as freezing when Tim was kidnapped and being unnerved by seeing the blood seemed very believable. But we also got to see that, although he knows and carries out the "Company policy," he is not such a bureaucrat that he believes it is right. And we see that he is not without his loyalties to people as well as the Company - he does have a conscience. SC did an outstanding job of acting out this episode. And obviously Webb has done a lot of practicing since "Game of Go," where he didn't even know what the safety was on a gun. <g> And you gotta love Webb for (a) having the courage to go to AJ for help in the first place and (b) being smart enough to recognize that AJ had superior knowledge in this kind of thing and being content to take orders rather than try to give them. It would not have surprised me to see Webb try to take the lead in the case - he did "recruit" the Admiral and he did have the contacts. But this was more a SEAL-type operation than a CIA one - they did make a great team, though. :) Then, of course, there was our beloved Admiral. Action AJ episodes are always among my favorites, and this one delivered in spades! A favorite fantasy of many on this list was to see Webb and AJ have to work together, and we could not have asked for a better episode. It was great to watch the uneasy dynamic between them - from AJ's initial distrust of Webb ("What's the game") to his concern over Webb's ability to actually complete the mission ("I know you've been in charge of operations where people have died, but have you ever killed anyone? Face to face?) and how it might impact on AJ's own survival ("Then all I have to worry about is you being a lousy shot:") to his grudging respect for Webb when he shares his story about Laos (but get a clue Webb - AJ *did* answer your question! <g>). It will be interesting to see how this affects future interactions between the two. It would appear that AJ's Italian is not quite as rusty as he would have had Marcella believe, though. But I could not quite decide whether that was JMJ speaking Italian or whether it was dubbed in. Loved his smile when he chased the two kids away from the fountain and loved his laugh at Decker's Italian. He doesn't get many chances to smile or laugh that it's always a treat when he does. :) And of course the reunion scene between AJ and Tim Fawkes was absolutely delightful - you don't often see men expressing such genuine emotion between them as was expressed in that reunion scene with the hugs and the laughs - that scene just made me grin like an idiot. <lol> Even the subplots here were fun. It was funny to see Harm still having to deal with his impulsive act of two years ago. Bet he never in a million years imagined the repercussions that would have! <vbg> Bud showed once again how smart he really is with that creative budgeting. Small nitpick, though, is that it seems unlikely that once again everyone senior to Harm would be unavailable to cover for AJ or that SECNAV would agree to allow Harm to play JAG again after the last time. But that's a minor point - I'll willingly accept it for the sake of where it took Harm. The whole car thing was funny - my DH talks about his cars the same way Harm talked about the 'vette. Even he recognized it and laughed about it. I can't even begin to imagine what Harriet's going to be packing for this kid if she thinks she needs a mini-van! But that actually made that whole thing pretty funny - mark my words - she'll either learn to pack much lighter real quick or she'll stop setting foot outside the house. :) The closing scene was hysterical - the little-kid-with-a-new-toy look on Mac's face when she drove up in the 'vette was priceless, as was the look on Harm's face. I don't suppose there's any chance Mac will come to her senses and go out with that police lieutenant?? Good-looking, charming, concerned, caring - get a move on, girl, he won't be around forever! <vbg> As I said when I started, many fans
have long wished for an episode where AJ and Webb had to
work together. Thank you to TPTB for not only listening
but for delivering such an absolutely wonderful script.
|
|
 |
Yeah Baby (aired May 18, 1999) |
| Review by Gray Cargill: Ratings: JAG: 4 AJ: 9 I'm sure it's no secret to anyone who has read my reviews of his previous scripts that Scott Gemmill is my least favorite of the writers in the JAG stable. (He has produced some exceptions--Jaggle Bells being one of my favorite episodes this year --but usually, I dislike his scripts.) This episode exemplified for me all of the traits that he brings to the page that make him my least favorite writer. First, what I liked about the episode: There was certainly nothing wrong with the concept, which was to deal with the birth of Bud and Harriet's baby and Harm's desire to return to being a pilot. So far, so good. It was great to see familiar faces like Jordan, Brumby, Imes, and Tiner. There were certainly several very amusing scenes. I loved the scene between AJ, Bud and Tiner and AJ shaking the snow globe; and Brumby's "Stop, you're embarrassing me" got a laugh out of me. One thing I can definitely give Gemmill credit for is that his greatest strength is that he is a funny writer. (That's also his greatest weakness, but I'll get back to that later.) While I ultimately agree with AJ, Jordan, and Mac that Harm is making a big mistake by wanting to go back to being a pilot, I respect his courage to try to do it again. Until he tries, he'll never know whether or not he could have done it or that it's right for him. As Nancy said (far better than I), he'd always wonder "what if". And it's always difficult to take what appears to the outside world to be a backward step in your career. Everyone in our culture is conditioned to think primarily of advancing their careers and consequently, their paychecks. But happiness doesn't always coincide with that. Minor quibble: When AJ tells Harm he might have to take orders from guys half his age and Harm replies that he doubts there are very many 17 year olds in flight squadrons and AJ references Harm being 34. . .Do TPTB honestly expect us to believe Harm is only 34? Wasn't he 35 when the show debuted back in '95? By my math, that makes him 39, unless he has some secret for reverse-aging that we don't know about. I loved the scene between Jordan and Harm re his decision. I thought her reaction was dead-on realistic. I'd have been hurt, too. I find myself torn in my response to Harm in this episode. On the one hand, I felt bad for him, because he just wanted everyone to understand what his decision meant to him and be supportive and no one was--except a reluctant AJ. On the other hand, he was (as usual) supremely insensitive to both Jordan and Mac. Yes, as he said, he had Jordan in mind, and that's why he hadn't made a decision yet, but this bit about his eye surgery has been going on for quite a while, and he never bothered to tell her about it, let alone what the ramifications could be. The only reason they were even discussing it was because she found out by accident. So I have mixed feelings about the way Harm was written here. I loved the AJ scenes--he's about the only character who consistently comes across in a positive light without being written "out of character". Thank God. The kitchen scene with Mac was good ("You're one of them...Did I say that out loud, sir?"). He was awesome in the delivery scene. When he said "Put your knees down darlin'" and handed the baby to her, that was very sweet. I would like to know, though, how he knew so much about delivering a baby. He must've been paying very close attention at Francesca's birth. Harriet is about the only other regular who came across fairly well in this episode. What a trooper. Unfortunately, I can't say the same for the rest of them, and herein lies my biggest problem with this episode, and Gemmill's writing in general. (How's that for a segue into "what I disliked about the episode"?) While it's true that Gemmill can be very funny at times, it's a juvenile sense of humor as a rule. It's my opinion that he too often sacrifices the integrity of the show's characters while reaching for a laugh. He either makes them the butt of jokes or writes them really out of character in the process of trying to be funny. No joke, gag, or laugh is worth that, IMO. So many characters were sacrificed on the altar of Gemmill's attempts to either garner laughs or pander to the 'shippers in this episode, I hardly know where to begin. All of the progress and growth we've seen in Bud this season to date was undermined when he was portrayed here as the stereotypical dufus new father. Not that other JAG writers don't also often use Bud as the butt of gags, but we've seen him become more of a grown-up this season, and I had hoped "Bud as the butt of jokes" was a thing of the past. Guess I was wrong. I disliked the storyline about the staff sergeant and the lance corporal; she seduced an officer under her command in order to get pregnant???? What, the woman's never heard of a sperm bank? Carolyn Imes, whom I normally like, made the really tasteless remark of "Maybe Bud could get us all pregnant." Yeah, that's all we need on the show: Bud's Harem. Brumby (who fared pretty well up until the last scenes) was the butt of the joke when he showed no understanding that delivering human babies might be slightly different from delivering sheep. Tiner was butt of the joke when he "fainted like a girl" ("did not!"). All of these scenes were written to garner a laugh, but at what cost? Is the policy here that it's really okay to make a character look dopey as long as the scene is funny? And how many more times do we have to sit through gags about men trying to decide whose is bigger? Mac's remark to Brumby and Harm was almost verbatim what Juanita Ressler said to Harm and Bertram back in Acts of Terror, and following on the heels of the gun exchange between AJ and Webb and the Porsche joke Mac made last week, I'm beginning to get really weary of this theme. Mac's character was once again trounced in this episode, first, in the following exchange:
Since when????? All season long, all we've seen is Mac being hostile and carping at Harm every time he looks even remotely wistful about his flying career. So if we take her at face value here, then what does that say about her? That she knows how much it means to him, but she's not going to be supportive because of selfish reasons. Talk about making Mac look bad. Speaking of which, I wish the writers would stop using Mac as a plot device and start treating her like a character in her own right again-- specifically, the fully-developed, well-rounded character she was last season. I thought with Second Sight that the disturbing trend of the season of treating Mac like a pawn on a chessboard was over, but no, it reared its ugly head again here. It's disheartening to see the one major female role model on this show constantly being undermined and turned into a simpering schoolgirl who turns from man to man to man, as if she feels she's lacking something by not having a man in her life. She wasn't like that before. So why, all of a sudden, is she now? And don't try to tell me it's because of her "biological clock." It's not like men aren't asking her out right and left, for God's sake. She should just relax and enjoy what she has--a great career, great friends, potential dates on all sides--and let the rest follow naturally. But no, she's got to agonize about it. (BTW, why the one-track mind about that in this episode? Every woman on the show was pining away to have a baby or a love interest or both, and Mac was reduced to having Chloe try to set her up with every man in sight. Why couldn't they have countered that with a woman who feels completely fulfilled without a love interest or a baby? Believe me, there are plenty of women like that out there. Are we to believe that no woman is supposed to be happy unless she's got a man on one arm and a baby in the other? That's a pretty limiting world view.) It is immensely sad to think that a woman like Mac who has so much going for her--beauty, brains, great legal skill, excellent combat skills, a great sense of humor, etc.--would actually want the kind of offer that Harm made at the end of this episode. She can do a hell of a lot better than that. It's too bad her self-esteem is so low that she doesn't realize it. Actually, I should say it's a crying shame that the writers are trying so hard to make Harm look like the kind of guy that any red-blooded woman would fall for that they had to reconstruct Mac's character to make her fit that mold, too. The thing I most admired about Mac when I first started watching this show last year was that she didn't fit that mold; she was the one woman around who wasn't swayed by Harm's looks or his "killer smile." She could hold her own with him, and she could flirt with him when she felt like it, but she wasn't going to fall at his feet like every other woman. She had more integrity (and, IMO, good sense) than that. Imagine how disappointing, then, the turn of events in that final scene was to me. And yes, I was extremely disappointed with the overt pandering to the 'shipper contingent in this episode. When the flirtation between Harm and Mac was mild, it was fun. Everyone flirts, it doesn't necessarily mean anything. You could take it or you could leave it, whichever you preferred. Shippers and non-shippers alike were happy. But stuff like this that slaps you in the face and feels so damn out of character for Mac really lessens my enjoyment of the show to practically nil. I think the mentality of this episode was aptly summed up by Chloe: "Harm and Mac, sitting in a tree, k-i-s-s-i-n-g." If that's Gemmill's idea of playing up to the shippers, I'm glad I'm not a shipper, because I'd be offended if I were. It certainly did not make the 'shipper viewpoint look like a very mature one. As always, the actors did as well as they could with what they were given to do (and some definitely fared better than others), and there were some redeeming scenes here, but I was pretty disappointed with this outing in and of itself, as well as for what it may bode for the future. I'm hoping it's an aberration. Favorite Quotes: AJ (picking up snow globe): This is your brain. (Shakes snow globe.) This is your brain during fatherhood. Any questions?
Review by Sue Valera: Ratings: JAG: 8 AJ: 10 What a wonderful episode! It flowed from the start to finish. Every one got a part to play from Tiner fainting to OFA efficiently taking charge at the end. This episode is close to being my favorite of the season. I could have done without the last scene between Harm and Mac. It reminded me of Cheers when Sam and Rebecca tried to have a baby. Stupid!!!! Forget the "cliffhanger" next week, this would have a nice way to end the season. Congratulations to the cast and crew . Review by Meg Bryant: Ratings: JAG: 9 AJ: 9 I absolutely LOVED this episode.... Not necessarily for all that happened in it (though I'm not complaining - it was all great), but because it was such a character-oriented episode (although I understand that a lot of fans DIDN'T like it for the same reason I liked it). We got a little bit of everyone, and the little bits were substantial bits. We gained major insight into all the main characters - we even learned more about Tiner in this ep than all the others we've seen him in put together. And speaking of Tiner... I adore this guy, and Chuck Carrington portrays him so wonderfully (I loved the petulant way he uttered his line "I did not" when Harriet was telling Mac he fainted). I hope we get to see lots more of him next season..... As for the Admiral - I loved seeing the Texan in him slip out when he called Harriet "darlin'." Bravo to all! Review by Lyn: JAG: 5 AJ: 9 I wanted to love this episode (I have a soft spot for "birthing" episodes in general) and there was so much that was really good about it, that it's unfortunate I was left with a sour taste in my mouth when it was over. Especially because it was so unnecessary. First off, I'm with Harm regarding Mac's reaction to his desire to return to flying. I didn't like it in "Shakedown," and I didn't like it last night either. Yes, I understand that Mac has had a lot of upsets in her life, and I understand that it seems as though everyone is leaving her. So I can understand her dismay at the prospect of losing her best friend, too. But Mac, above all people, should know how much flying means to Harm, and considering how often she has put aside her personal feelings to support Harm in his various quests, I fully expected her to acknowledge that, although it will hurt her, she is happy that Harm will finally get a chance to fulfill his lifelong dream. Hopefully after she's had a chance to assimilate what's happening, she'll find it in her heart to support him in this. She should come to realize that it was inevitable. If she or Jordan or the Admiral or anyone else managed to talk Harm out of trying to become a fighter pilot again, he would always wonder what "might have been." He would never have any real peace or any chance to be really happy as a lawyer. He needs to go back to flying, if only to find out where his heart really lies. If he tries and it doesn't work out, then it will be *his* decision that being a lawyer is where he really belongs. Otherwise, he'll always view a decision to remain at JAG as a compromise. He just needs to do this. As for the Admiral, well his reaction was just exactly what I expected it to be. He is not happy about losing his best lawyer, but in the end, he did as he always does. He put aside his own personal feelings to support Harm - and then did it to the best of his ability, including going to the SECNAV for a favor, something which he was loathe to do and which now puts him in the hated position of owing SECNAV a favor. It's unfortunate that Harm will never fully understand just exactly what AJ did for him and so will never fully appreciate it. But we know, and we salute you, Admiral. Gotta love Tiner for trying to cheer up Harriet, but you just knew that was going to blow up in his face. The scene with AJ, Bud, and Tiner was hysterical. AJ (picking up snowglobe): This is your brain. (shaking snowglobe): This is your brain during fatherhood. Any questions? That had me laughing out loud. Loved Brumby tonight. I thought his interactions with Mac in the elevator and then at her apartment were very nicely done. I like Brumby more and more all the time, and I'm looking forward to seeing more of him next year. The interaction with Harm about delivering babies was funny, and he got me - I was not expecting the bit about the sheep. Mac's comment about Dr. Doolittle was perfect. Then we have Tiner. What a cutie. And the way he stepped in seemingly so confident and sure of himself, only to faint. Two down and one to go - OFA of course. What can I say about AJ delivering the baby except that scene also went exactly as I would have expected. He steps in, takes charge, and does a beautiful job. It was so great to see him so excited about the baby and so careful ("cover the medals") - I think he had almost as much invested in this baby as Bud and Harriet did. I hope we'll get at least a few chances to see him interact with Little AJ next season - AJ is so wonderful with children. I can't help but wonder how much of that is JMJ showing through. :) And I am very grateful that so far all the writers seem to understand this character. I don't think we've ever seen him act "out of character" as we have with some of the others - he's not perfect, but he is a very good man. As far as I’m concerned, they
should have ended the episode right after the Admiral
said, "Never a dull moment here," and walked
back into the building. Had they done that, I could have
stood the scene between Chloe and Mac in Mac’s
apartment with much more equanimity. Instead we got this
distasteful closing scene of two heretofore intelligent
people making a stupid pact to "go halves" on a
baby in five years if neither one has found anyone
better. Quite simply, the less said about that scene, the
better. It was ill-conceived and ill-executed and would
have been better off left out. And coupled with the scene
in Mac’s apartment, it left this viewer angry and
irritated instead of cheerful and upbeat as I should have
been after the successful birth of the Roberts’
baby. What a very disappointing finish to an otherwise
excellent outing.
|
|
| Goodbyes (aired May 25, 1999) | |
| Review by Gray Cargill Ratings: JAG: 7.5 AJ: 7.5 For the most part, I really enjoyed this episode. It was one of the better ones we've seen this season. Probably a major reason for that is that it followed up on the events of Nobody's Child and guest-starred the always excellent Erik Todd Dellums (former Luther Mahoney, Homicide: Life on the Streets) as the psychotic Charlie Lynch. This man is a fabulous actor. He was just chilling, wasn't he? Scary, scary dude. I was glad to get an explanation for Charlie's behavior (his past). Someone doesn't just turn out to be that way for no reason at all. Of course, that doesn't mean he can be rehabilitated. On the one hand, the episode took a very old formula--bad guy stalks innocent victim, good guy confronts bad guy and saves innocent victim--but on the other hand, the way they wrote it was pretty satisfying for me, for the most part (although I have a few quibbles, which I will get to). I think what made it particularly good was very strong acting from the regulars and guest stars--especially Erik Todd Dellums, Susan Haskell, and Alysia Polk--and the fact that Stephen Zito took the time to show us just how invested the characters were in everything that was going on. The events of this episode really impacted people. I found myself on the proverbial edge of my seat as they juxtaposed the scenes of the christening with the scenes of Charlie looking for Dar-Lin. I had this horrible feeling for a little while there that they were going to have him kill her. All I could think of was: Not another dead kid, please. We've already had 2 on the show this year. I on't think I could handle it again. I really appreciated that they didn't show the string of murders that occurred during this episode. It's just as effective to leave the actual murders to the imagination of the viewers. But at the same time, because we didn't actually see Charlie attack Harm, I got the impression that we were being led to believe that Harm might not have killed Charlie in self-defense. I am sure he did. Here's one quibble: Why, oh why, does Harm always have to try to be the lone hero? In this case, when he goes to the shipyard alone to find Charlie and Dar-Lin, what made him think he was even remotely equipped to handle that situation? Charlie has already killed a stringful of people, he's got this helpless child at his mercy, and Harm goes in alone. As far as I know, he's never been trained in hostage negotiations, and he's not a psychiatrist, so he doesn't have the training in "talking a psycho down", so to speak. He could have gotten that kid killed. I can sort of forgive the writer for this, though, only because they took the time to show that Harm actually had been listening to what Jordan said about Charlie. It was Jordan's words, not Harm's, coming out of his mouth during his confrontation with Charlie. That shows at least a little good sense on his part. Speaking of Jordan, I see what they meant about the scene between Jordan and Harm. While she seemed to be talking about Dar-Lin, it felt more like she was talking about herself and her relationship with Harm. I was surprised there was no overt scene of the two breaking up. Does that mean she's not necessarily out of the picture? I hope not, because I really like the character of Jordan. Even if she and Harm break up, I'd still like to see her return once in awhile to assist on cases. I think, given the kinds of cases they deal with and the kind of villains who turn up--the Palmers and Charlies of the world--they could really use someone with the skills of a psychiatrist. Re Harm leaving JAG: I felt kind of sorry for Harm when AJ didn't relent at the end and wish him well (I mean he did, but it was more perfunctory than sincere). You could tell Harm really wanted AJ's approval. While I thought Catherine's acting was terrific here--she plays emotional scenes very well--I am still disappointed in the current way Mac is being written. The Mac/Harm scenes felt forced and manipulated to me. I cannot imagine why TPTB suddenly feel the need to shoehorn these two characters together when they're such a bad romantic match for each other. Hint: Just because they're the two leads doesn't mean they automatically belong together. And in the process of trying to force them into that mold, they make Mac look like some schoolgirl with a crush, instead of the competent professional she used to be. What a waste. And as far as Harm and Mac becoming AJ's godparents....how cliche. Like we couldn't have seen that coming a hundred miles away. What was up with the flashes between scenes? Don't they usually use that device for flashbacks, not same-time segues? In any case, I really didn't like it at all. It was distracting. Appearance by Skates: I know some fans have been clamoring to see her again. Personally, I could have lived with or without her scenes. I did, however, love her fiance's description of Harm as an "aging retread." I have a feeling he's in for a lot more of that when he ends up on that carrier next season. Even though I thought this was a better season finale in some ways than To Russia With Love, I won't be spending this summer on pins and needles waiting for season 5 the way I did last summer waiting for season 4. This is because, as a whole, I found season 4 to be a major disappointment compared to season 3. So my final thoughts are: "Thank God this season is over. I hope next year is better." Favorite quotes:
Review by Yankee Rose: Ratings: JAG: AJ: I thought tonight's episode was good. I loved all of AJ's scenes, especially the one with Mac about Harm leaving JAG. It was ironic that she had tears in her eyes talking about Harm leaving to AJ, whom she knows is attracted to her. He pretty much slams her about her past resignation that she submitted, then tells her it's a mistake to get too close to people you work with. Mac seemed shocked at his hard ass attitude towards her. But you think she would have realized how much it must have ticked him off to see her crying about Harm. AJ was so good at being surly tonight, I loved it. That Charlie guy returns to kill a few more people, then kidnaps Darla and takes her to the Philadelphia Naval Shipyards. Harm locates Charlie's car there, calls and tells the cops where he is, and is told to wait for back up. Harm decides to go it alone, and ends up shooting Charlie in self defense... killing him. Little AJ was baptized. The whole gang was there for that. At the end... Harm gets his orders for a flight billet at NAS Pensacola. He says his good-byes... and leaves. Brumby takes over for Harm. I think it's really nice how they have Harm giving the telephone number for the Lost Child hotline at the end of the show. I'm sure at least one child will be helped by the info given, and it's really something special for a major network drama to promote such a worthy cause. A real touch of class. All in all a pretty good episode. I give it a 2 out of 5 on the YR scale...
Review by Lyn: JAG: 7 AJ: 8 Well, last year I thought the season ended with a bang. This year it seems to have gone out with a whimper. Two episodes in a row that should have been really good but that ended up leaving me feeling disappointed - as if the writers really missed out on the chance to do something great. First off, what I liked - the storyline about Charlie. Kudos to whoever cast the part of Charlie. What a wonderful choice! As my husband remarked at one point, "Man that is one scary guy." He did a marvelous job. I really liked the way they switched back and forth between "our heroes" and Charlie - it was a little unsettling at times (especially during the christening), which I think is part of what made it so effective. The little girl who played Dar-Lin was once again terrific. Jordan once again showed strength and courage - too bad she's leaving. I really liked her. Loved when Harm is talking about how it must have been hard for her given their situation, and she tells him, "This isn't about me." You go, girl! As one who tends to make everything about him, it must have been somewhat of a shock to Harm to get blown off like that. Of course, as soon as we heard Agent Holland tell Harm to wait for backup, we all knew he was going to assume she was talking to that invisible guy standing next to him and forge ahead on his own. Does this man never learn? The last time he did that (Silent Service), he nearly got himself and Mac both killed. If he had gone in to do a little reconnaissance - see where Charlie and Dar-Lin were, scope out the situation, and then had gone back out to check on reinforcements, I wouldn't have minded it so much. But that was a very volatile situation he was walking into with no particular training on his part to handle it. It was stupid and arrogant, and he's lucky he didn't get Dar-Lin or himself (or both) killed. And, of course, it probably goes without saying (although I'll say it anyway <vbg>), I loved AJ - even though he didn't have that much to do. I thought he handled Mac very well when she came in to see him. You have to wonder whether, when he told her it was a mistake to get too attached to a billet or to people, he was saying that for her benefit or for his own - a little bit of both I suspect. I liked that, although he refused to coddle Harm by telling him he thought he was making the right choice, he did wish him luck. Showed class. It will be interesting to see how he treats Harm when he does come back to JAG (and I don't think anyone seriously believes he won't be back - it's more a question of how long he'll be gone). He made Mac pay for leaving (and I have to assume when he said he thought long and hard before taking her back that he meant before deciding to keep her at HQ. He let her return to JAG immediately - in fact, he'd never processed her paperwork. It'll be a little bit different when Harm comes back.) Considering that he seemed to look on Harm as sort of a surrogate son as well as a protege, one would expect that Harm would have to work pretty hard to regain his "golden boy" status at JAG. Quite frankly, that's one of the few things I'm looking forward to for next season (along with hoping that we continue to see OFA featured more prominently as he was this season) and hoping desperately that TPTB don't just decide to sweep the whole thing under the carpet. What I didn't like - basically Harm and Mac. (If not for the scene between them at the end, this episode would have ranked higher, as the A-line about Charlie was excellent.) Overall, Harm once again demonstrated, as he has so often during the show's entire run, that he has no real deep feelings for anyone. Although he supposedly loved Annie, when she told him not to call, he just accepted it and abandoned her and Josh, whom he also claimed to love. When Jordan says to call her when he makes up his mind, that’s just okay with him. He did not demonstrate any deep feelings for Bud. He wanted AJ's approval of his transfer but not enough to have gone to him beforehand and discussed what he was thinking. I was really glad when AJ cut him off - he was launching into this insincere speech that no doubt would have been more about him and what he wanted. He no doubt thought he could make a nice speech and flash that grin and all would be forgiven. It was a shock to him to realize he wasn't going to get away with it. As for his goodbye scene with Mac, again he seemed to have a momentary twinge of remorse when he realized he'd caused her pain, but there was no sense that it was going to bother him overmuch. He seemed more bothered by the fact that everyone thought he was making a bad decision than by the fact that he was leaving his friends. Which brings me to Mac. I really didn't think she could sink any lower, but boy was I wrong! I was seriously pissed off at her when she went to the Admiral to try to get him to keep Harm at JAG. In the first place, she of all people should know from her own experience that the Admiral would not want to keep anyone at JAG who did not want to be there. In the second place, who the heck does she think she is to try to usurp Harm's decisions? What right does she have to be trying to make life/career choices for anyone else? Get a grip, Marine! It's Harm life, it's Harm's career, and it's his right and his alone to decide what he's going to do with it. You don't have to like it and you don't have to support it, but you do not get to try to order other people's lives to suit you. With that one scene, she proved how incredibly self-centered and neurotic she’s become. Then we get that truly pathetic parting scene in Harm's office. She's fallen a long way from the "We The People" Mac who told Harm that his smile was very charming and probably got him what he wanted most of the time but it wouldn't work with her to the pathetic emotional cripple who can't handle her best friend's transfer to another billet. Mac used to be one of the few really strong and well-written female characters on television - an especially notable accomplishment given the lack of female writers on the show. Now she's pretty much useless, and it is so very aggravating to watch. At this point, it might not be a bad
idea for Mac to wake up on the season opener and find
Harm in her shower. Then we could all get back to the JAG
we grew to love - the one with the interesting cases and
dynamic courtroom action where the character development
was believable and served as a nice undercurrent to round
out the show.
|
|
| JMJ On Television |  (JMJ as Peter Arnold in "Eve of Destruction")
(JMJ as Johnny B. in "The Spitfire Grill") |
|||
| (Unless otherwise specified, all times shown are Eastern Standard Time) | ||||
| June 1 | 8 p.m. | CBS | JAG: "Webb of Lies" | |
| June 6 | 8 p.m. | TBS | "The Spitfire Grill" (1996)* | |
| June 8 | 8 p.m. | CBS | JAG: "Rivers' Run" | |
| June 12 | 9 p.m. | LIFE | "Deadly Matrimony" (1992)* | |
| June 19 | 5 p.m. | SCIFI | "Eve of Destruction" (1990)* | |
| June 22 | 8 p.m. | CBS | JAG: "Dungaree Justice" | |
| June 22 | 8 p.m. | CBS | JAG: "War Stories" | |
| June 29 | 8 p.m. | CBS | JAG: "Silent Service" | |
| June 29 | 8 p.m. | CBS | JAG: "Innocence" | |
*There are reviews of these movies in the JMJAS JMJ Movie Review section of this website.
This JMJ On Television feature will be updated during the summer to include July and August listings as they become available. Check back after the first of each month to see where you will be able to find JMJ on your set.
Except as otherwise noted, all articles are original compositions for this newsletter. If you download any articles or photographs for use on your website, please give appropriate credit to this newsletter as follows: "Taken from The Jackson Journal, Summer1999 edition." We also ask that you create a link from your website to "The John M. Jackson Admiration Society" page at http://www.oocities.org/Hollywood/Bungalow/6826/ Thank you.
 |
 |
 |
